Team Guide by CasterMaster

76%
65 Votes
Rate Up LoL GuideRate Down LoL Guide
League of Legends Build Guide Author CasterMaster

A Fantasy's Guide Review Store

CasterMaster Last updated on October 15, 2012
72,722 162
Comments (page 13 of 17)
Quote | PM | +Rep
by Amazing Monkey » June 30, 2012 7:55pm | Report

Name: Amazing Monkey
Summoner Level: 30
Guide Name: Sun Wukong- Great Sage Equal to Heaven
Who you want to review your guide: Anyone who hasn't already. I'm not picky!
Why do you want it reviewed?: My guide USUALLY resides within the top 3 or 4. I'd like to ensure that it provides the most useful information, to better the Mobafire community.

(Since you have so many reviewers, can I do two?? If yes, here's my other guide, Shyvana- Justice Under Dragon's Wings. Same reasoning as the other one =3)



If you felt I contributed and stuff, can I have a (+1 Rep =3)?
Need a sig? Come get one for free at Amazing Monkey's Community Sig Shop!
View my Wukong Guide- Great Sage Equal to Heaven, Shyvana Guide- Justice Under Dragon's Wings, or NEW Lulu Guide- Whimsical Wonders of the Imagination! Yay!
Special thanks to Miss Maw, Lazukin, Leipetaco, Xiaowiriamu, LaCorpse, and SarcasmAppreciated for the sigs!
Amazing Monkey's Forum Avatar
Amazing Monkey
Notable (59)

Posts: 890
Joined: 2012-04-10
IGN: Amazing Monkey on NA
View My Blog
Quote | PM | +Rep
by Embracing » July 6, 2012 8:44pm | Report

Name: RosePhoenix
Summoner Level: 30
Guide Name Reverent Riven, an In-Depth Riven Guide by RosePhoenix
Who you want to review your guide: Anybody who hasn't looked at it yet
Why do you want it reviewed? Would like some unbiased feedback.


Embracing's Forum Avatar
Embracing
<Veteran>
Distinguished (235)

Posts: 3731
Joined: 2011-02-02
IGN: Embracing on NA
View My Blog
Quote | PM | +Rep
by PigsCanFly238 » July 8, 2012 1:29pm | Report

Name: Pigscanfly238
Summoner Level:22
Guide Name:Fiora,Hybrid Solo Top
Who Do I want to review:Anyone
Why do I want it reviewed: I know this really doesn't meet the requirements but this is my first guide and I've even read jhoijhois guide making guide twice and nothing makes sense at all. I'd appreciate someone to give me assistance in it,as it would make my dream of having a popular guide. Email me at cameron.o.j@gmail.com,reply to this,or even skype me at pigscanfly238 if you can help. Thanks a milion


PigsCanFly238's Forum Avatar
PigsCanFly238

Posts: 7
Joined: 2012-05-21
IGN: Pigscanfly238 on NA
Quote | PM | +Rep
by tryhardtyler » July 9, 2012 10:12am | Report

name: Tryhardtyler

Summoner Level: 30

Guide Name: http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/sion-2012-ranked-carry-all-builds-included-ad-ap-tank-jungle-177776

Who you want to review your guide: no preference.

Why do you want it reviewed? I would like to see what more distingished members of the mobafire community think of the quality of my guide. I would also like more suggestions for what to add. Thank you in advance :)


tryhardtyler's Forum Avatar
tryhardtyler
Unremarkable (9)

Posts: 34
Joined: 2011-09-14
IGN: TryHardTyler on NA
Quote | PM | +Rep
by smiLiwaT » July 9, 2012 10:13am | Report


Name: Amazing Monkey
Summoner Level: 30
Guide Name: Sun Wukong- Great Sage Equal to Heaven
Who you want to review your guide: Anyone who hasn't already. I'm not picky!
Why do you want it reviewed?: My guide USUALLY resides within the top 3 or 4. I'd like to ensure that it provides the most useful information, to better the Mobafire community.

(Since you have so many reviewers, can I do two?? If yes, here's my other guide, Shyvana- Justice Under Dragon's Wings. Same reasoning as the other one =3)


Latley im just loving top lane and as a one of reviewers ill take a look at it.

SMITE FTW.

Build it self


Guide it self

  • <3 the intro image. I just should point it out.
  • Your guide doesnt looks beautiful. Sorry but it is true. Images aren't on the same lines as text's and you could really focuse on layout of your guide . Use more BB codes like the most basic one
    .
  • Your Masterie page is lacking. You could explain all the maseries and how Wu benefits from them.
  • About Rune page , you should take down the count of rune like x9 or x3 , people know that you can't have 9 Quints :D
  • Add information to your whole guide , it's lacking of information and details that are really important
  • Mybe its just me but i don't really like your used moba -> masterie trees / item bars / rune bars (those collumns that you use in your rune and item section)
  • I realllllllllly like the details of other top laners. I read few of them and i really think that they are worth reading.
  • As you said your guide is a work in proggres.

In general



I liked your guide and i think that it will become more in-depth upon time , but you have to put some time in it. You need to try more situations and from then add details.

I would say that it's a good starters guide.

My rating about guide 7/10 .

This was my review , here will be results for Store
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Visual - Same as BB code i will give 6/10 but you can and have to improve it if you want to get till 90%

Quality - 7/10 , really decent guide i would even say in depth.

Information - 7/10 , you got lots of it but i would like to see tips & tricks section

Grammar - <9000 , i dont review grammar so it will be over 9000.


smiLiwaT's Forum Avatar
smiLiwaT
Notable (25)

Posts: 165
Joined: 2011-10-02
IGN: smiLiwaT on EUW
View My Blog
Quote | PM | +Rep
by smiLiwaT » July 9, 2012 10:36am | Report

[

Quoted:

Name: RosePhoenix
Summoner Level: 30
Guide Name Reverent Riven, an In-Depth Riven Guide by RosePhoenix
Who you want to review your guide: Anybody who hasn't looked at it yet
Why do you want it reviewed? Would like some unbiased feedback.




Build it self

  • Masteries - I got few ideas about changing them -> Tought skin to 1x Resistance and 1x Hardiness , so it would benefit you more for trading.
  • Like your runes , but i would advice to add one Greater Quintessence of Health. It will synergy with Durability and Veteran's Scars .
  • Your build is really farm dependent , but if there is situation that you can't manage to get farm ? or like 2v1 lane where your farm and EXP gain is denied ?
  • I saw Randuin's Omen so advice to take hearth of gold a bit later , after boots so you would benefit from it, Also it will help in situation above.
  • It just me but i prefer Riven as a sustainable high damage dealer that can hold in all fights.

Guide it self

  • I like the style of your guide. But to my mind you could improve it by adding one color, with that one color you could highlight some important parts , it will make text easier 2 read and readers will just see highlighted words and find all they need faster
  • In masterie page i would sugest to take off that MOBA collumn of masteries as it's useless if you use images from LoL Launcher.
  • I like the style of Summoner spells , since i use same style ^^
  • Love your combo list, they are really helpfull for newbies
  • Also Love your item section its really detailed and well-written
  • But i really advice to make a build with Tanky Riven
  • Im just sooooo jelouse about your Lane Matchup section best one that i have seen so far.
  • And the last , but no least the jungle section is just AWESOME i really enjoy jungle riven since her ganks are OP.

In general

    Your build is really good and guide is detailed , you can expand it and make the layout better.

    I am more used to bruiser riven but your build might work to ( ill give it a try)


My rating about guide 9/10 .

This was my review , here will be results for Store
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Visual - 9/10 I liked it but you can add some colors or stuff

Quality - 10/10 , really decent guide i would even say in depth.

Information - 9/10

Grammar - <9000 , i dont review grammar so it will be over 9000.


smiLiwaT's Forum Avatar
smiLiwaT
Notable (25)

Posts: 165
Joined: 2011-10-02
IGN: smiLiwaT on EUW
View My Blog
Quote | PM | +Rep
by smiLiwaT » July 9, 2012 11:37am | Report


Name: Pigscanfly238
Summoner Level:22
Guide Name:Fiora,Hybrid Solo Top
Who Do I want to review:Anyone
Why do I want it reviewed: I know this really doesn't meet the requirements but this is my first guide and I've even read jhoijhois guide making guide twice and nothing makes sense at all. I'd appreciate someone to give me assistance in it,as it would make my dream of having a popular guide. Email me at cameron.o.j@gmail.com,reply to this,or even skype me at pigscanfly238 if you can help. Thanks a milion


Im reviewer from Fantasy's Review store - smiLiwaT. and i will review your guide, i hope that you can give me feedback and rate on my guides.


Build it self


Guide it self

  • Mm there is no guide. YOU MUST WORK ON IT. on moba you don't make build you make GUIDES + BUILDS.

In general


You got so maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaany things to improve , i guess that's work in progress but you need to make a guide and complete it , then send it to review.

My rating about guide 5/10 Only because of decent build.

This was my review , here will be results for Store
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Visual - 0/10 I liked it but you can add some colors or stuff

Quality - 0/10 , really decent guide i would even say in depth.

Information - 0/10

Grammar - <9000 , i dont review grammar so it will be over 9000.


smiLiwaT's Forum Avatar
smiLiwaT
Notable (25)

Posts: 165
Joined: 2011-10-02
IGN: smiLiwaT on EUW
View My Blog
Quote | PM | +Rep
by smiLiwaT » July 9, 2012 12:34pm | Report


name: Tryhardtyler

Summoner Level: 30

Guide Name: http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/sion-2012-ranked-carry-all-builds-included-ad-ap-tank-jungle-177776

Who you want to review your guide: no preference.

Why do you want it reviewed? I would like to see what more distingished members of the mobafire community think of the quality of my guide. I would also like more suggestions for what to add. Thank you in advance :)



Im reviewer from Fantasy's Review store - smiLiwaT. and i will review your guide, i hope that you can give me feedback and rate on my guides.


Build 1


Build 2



Build 3

  • Yeah it's pretty much same as your 1.st build.
  • But as a tanky ou could rush Death's Caress insted of Enrage because you are a tank.


Build 4



Guide it self

  • You should add more visual material like Pictures / Vidos. And just delet those random colored texts as it only messes with reading and you can't concetrate. I would suggest to take 1 color and highlight all the main words
  • Pros&Cons - Take off those spaaaaaaaace, page looks unbalanced.
  • Edit your masterie page, you can check out other guides and "borrow" some ideas.
  • I would also add some Tips&tricks to your "Skill Sequence" and "Ability Explanation"

In general



You got lots of things to improve to you guide, lots of information that you could add , use lolwiki it will help you.


My rating about guide 8/10

This was my review , here will be results for Store
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Visual - 6/10 I liked it but you can add some colors or stuff

Quality - 8/10 , really decent guide i would even say in depth.

Information - 8/10

Grammar - <9000 , i dont review grammar so it will be over 9000.


smiLiwaT's Forum Avatar
smiLiwaT
Notable (25)

Posts: 165
Joined: 2011-10-02
IGN: smiLiwaT on EUW
View My Blog
Quote | PM | +Rep
by PigsCanFly238 » July 9, 2012 2:26pm | Report

smiLiwaT wrote:



Im reviewer from Fantasy's Review store - smiLiwaT. and i will review your guide, i hope that you can give me feedback and rate on my guides.


Build it self


Guide it self

  • Mm there is no guide. YOU MUST WORK ON IT. on moba you don't make build you make GUIDES + BUILDS.

In general


You got so maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaany things to improve , i guess that's work in progress but you need to make a guide and complete it , then send it to review.

My rating about guide 5/10 Only because of decent build.

This was my review , here will be results for Store
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Visual - 0/10 I liked it but you can add some colors or stuff

Quality - 0/10 , really decent guide i would even say in depth.

Information - 0/10

Grammar - <9000 , i dont review grammar so it will be over 9000.

Thanks for your feedback,I have barely made this guide public and I really need hellp setting up pros/cons and stuff like i said,could you provide the help for that? Thanks a million,
Pig.


PigsCanFly238's Forum Avatar
PigsCanFly238

Posts: 7
Joined: 2012-05-21
IGN: Pigscanfly238 on NA
Quote | PM | +Rep
by Anastasios » July 9, 2012 2:33pm | Report

Name: Anastasios
Summoner Level: 30
Guide Name: Malignant Malzahar 2.0
Who you want to review your guide: Arcana3
Why do you want it reviewed? I published it a few days ago, so now i'm going aroung in review shops to improve it as much as possible.



Many thanks to MissMaw, LaCorpse, Xiron, Arcana3 and Joxuu for making me sigs!
Anastasios's Forum Avatar
Anastasios
Prominent (81)

Posts: 1023
Joined: 2011-12-19
View My Blog

Quick Reply


Please log in or register to comment!

Mobafire

General Guides

League of Legends

More Guides

The Charts


Featured

30 Days

All Time

Popular
Top Guide by Champion

This Week's Free Champions

Free Champion: Free Champion: Free Champion: Free Champion: Free Champion: Free Champion: Free Champion: Free Champion: Free Champion: Free Champion:

About the Author

CasterMaster
Veteran

More Guides from CasterMaster

MFTV

Latest on MOBAFire TV

More Mobafire Video

Scheduled Tournaments

MOBAFire Community Cup NA May
Registration Open
Dominate Dominion #57
Finished
Dominate TT #10 (NA)
Finished
Dominate Dominion #56
Finished

Drop-in Games

MOBAFire Inhouses
Registration Open