The reason for Black Cleaver over Malady is that the BC gives a great advantage when it comes mid game. At that point, very few enemy champs have significant armor, and whatever armor they have is essentially neutralized by the BC. I tried Malady, but I found that with Black Cleaver, you are hitting HARD where as with Malady you are doing about 1/2 as much damage. Malady might prove better late game, but to help snowball in lane and tear down single targets, BC is better.

I like the idea of the Frozen Mallet to to make Kayle more tanky and add even more slow to her bag of tricks. Guardian Angel is also a nice add. Seems like you build more for tanking and aggressive support than dealing outright damage which is a perfectly viable build for Kayle. I'm with blastantir though about the Malady. The AP is nice and makes you a bit more of a threat due to the stacking of MR reduction on top of her passive.

+1 for the guide though. Keep up the good work.

I like the Malady, but I find that Black Cleaver hits harder and benefits the team more. And Nashor's is necessary for the CDR, Attack Speed, and sustain of mana regen.

Will be refining in time. First guide!

This guide is good and the build is ok.. i usually take a Malady but the concept is quite similar. take my +1

Just try to add some detain ;)

maybe you can read and vote my guide too