So, live up the good life before RIOT nerfs Blackfire Torch. The amount of damage it give Alistar is just stupid good. After it, you mainly need to just go tanky. Rush the Thornmail more if there are more auto-attack champs like yi or tryn. I'm not a doctor, but I do believe his passive will proc the blackfire torch. If not, it has still been doing a stupid amount of damage. Amumu and Brand are pretty fun with the torch too.
Yay first guide done, now time to wait for the new items to make one that actually matters!