Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 16th, 2013
"Awesome guide, exactly how I like to build Gangplank too! :)
Great details and info, but consider doing something extra with formatting. Columns, line dividers, and more color. Also possibly spoilers. These will all make your guide prettier to read."
Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 14th, 2013
"Hi there!
I figured that you might appreciate a review on this instead of your rengar guide since it is still a fresh guide that needs more attention.
Great use of formatting and columns. Good bb-code. So much color! Nice aesthetics.
[spoiler=Wi"
Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 14th, 2013
"I agree, Liandry's Torment is getting too much attention. Honestly, I feel like if people want bonus damage after their spells, they should just get Lich Bane and learn to proc spell-blade between spell-casts. It does a hell of a lot more damage and synergizes better on most champs than Lian"
Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 14th, 2013
"How about a rule that anyone who has a troll-vote in their recent activity will be blacklisted from the Request que and will not receive a review?"
Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 14th, 2013
"
Yeah, I know. I just wish there was a better way to keep shmucks from ruining guide ratings. It irritates me when I see a good guide with a 75% rating and a downvote that says something like, "wtf <insert item name here>?!?! are you retarded?" or, "You're"
Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 13th, 2013
"
We"
Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 12th, 2013
"How about we include plugs for each reviewer, for example:
Username:
Review types offered:
Pet Peeves: (AKA don't ask me to review a guide with these things in it)
etc..."
Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 12th, 2013
"
I should have made it clear what the thread is for, this is a discussion page I started. I personally PM'd the people I knew were interested in joining the review circle with a link to this so we would have a way to discuss request/review rules. It will eventually contain "
Commented
Posted a Comment: Feb 12th, 2013
"Some starter questions:
What should be encompassed as rules all reviewers have to follow, and what should be left up to each person to decide how they want to do things?
How should we handle rude people? Should we have some sort of mass down-vote threat to people who troll vote?
Feel free t"
Thread
Created a Thread In General Discussion On: Feb 12th, 2013
A Review Circle: rules and methods discussion
This first post is reserved to maintain a list of the current rules and other important information.