This is a good guide and I like the comparison you did between BT, HxGB, and BotRK.

I didn't try IE first, because IE works better with some crit's and Poppy really need the sustain the BotRK gives.
And the BotRK helps a lot to catch an opponent, IE is better when you can tuch them ^^

Looks like a fun build, I'll try it out. Have you tried getting IE before BotRK?

Don't mind the ignoramus who posted that first comment.

Actualy, this is a top guide... I don't see any reason to play poppy bot nor play her as a tank

Edit : And if you had really read this you would have seen some video of me at top

This guide is turning out to be a bust...

Consider this. You're suggesting a tank be built like a carry and then put bottom against a real carry.

1. This defeats the entire point of a carry bot; they're ranged for a reason, and it's because they are team fights' long-range damage.
2. Poppy is way too ineffective against people with lots of poke. Kill lane or not, it would be hell attempting a laning phase with her bot.
3. She's a tank, not anything else. Also, she's best built AP, not AD.

Reconsider what you really want with this guide, or maybe broadly restructure hwo you would o bot lane Poppy.