This is really for people without a lot of experience with the game, I don't think someone that has been playing for a decent amount of time should be looking for guides unless they're trying to get back into the game. I understand each and every point you made but there is a reason in my mind (which I guess I didn't make clear, made this guide a while ago though). I should edit this guide in my spare time.

Thank you for your time.

hi why put 1 point in butcher with this ammount of AD last hitting should not be a problem imo.
masteries are wrong you cant get "second wind" without putting 3x pts into "perseverance".

the 7x AD rune glyphs for 1.96 AD (before any armor reduction) is really useless you should go for some cdr/mr/mana.

keep in mind gauntlet still really usefull vs heavy ad team or just ad matchups, if u talk about building a thornmail i suppose you could replace mercurys by tabi ninja if ennemies arent not CCrollers.

+note : ability sequence makes no sense you as ad nida bruiser you should max at first the E increasing your AttackSpeed to spam more aa especially full AD runes setup and it would be more benefic for sustain.
maxing Q without AP isnt the good way to pressure ennemies if u considere a spear = 2aa and cost a lot of mana.