Petition:Overwork of the "Require comment...

[quote=sAlatji]Change it from "write something offtopic/useless" to "write a decent feedback with your arguments why you downvote the guide, otherwise vote will get deleted" Your thoughts?[/quote]

[quote=lifebaka]So, basically, "upvote me or I delete your vote"?[/quote]

[quote=BusDriver210][quote=lifebaka] So, basically, "upvote me or I delete your vote"? [/quote] I'm a little bit tired of these voting arguments. Each player has their entitled opinion, positive or negative.[/quote]

[quote=JEFFY40HANDS]Freedom of speech/press....So what if their words or opinions might consist of "OBJECTION". Be thankful you have a similar right to do the same. And rather than create a whole thread about it, drop it off in the QQ thread (because that is all this is). I agree that people SHOULD write valid, intelligent, detailed arguments as to why they disagree with a guide. But that doesn't mean they have to. As a thought though, the upvote/downvote system on the League forums might be a safer more respectful solution. If a comment gets enough downvotes it fades out and/or is removed.[/quote]

[quote=BusDriver210]Here is something to chew on. Both your current guides are unorthodox support guides. There is nothing wrong with creating a unorthodox guide, but when I read both of them it only took me about 3 minutes each. They provide very little information beyond what items to buy. On top of that both guides are kind of "walls of text". If you are looking for upvotes and to be a top rated guide you need to put in a great deal more effort. You need to make your guide longer, flow better, and overall look nicer. Compared to the top guides, your guide is lacking in a lot of departments. The best advice I can offer is to continue to work on your guides and make them stand out from the sea of other watered down guides.[/quote]

[quote=FalseoGod]I think it should have a decent minimum word limit, so it'll require more than "nice guide" or "this sucks" to get an up/downvote[/quote]

[quote=Crows foot][quote=FalseoGod] I think it should have a decent minimum word limit, so it'll require more than "nice guide" or "this sucks" to get an up/downvote [/quote] This[/quote]

[quote=sAlatji][quote=lifebaka] So, basically, "upvote me or I delete your vote"? [/quote] no, but giving a decent feedback/comment why you downvoted a guide. Right now you can post whatever you want and downvote. http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/the-way-do-foxfire-damage-231234/discussion Just check some downvotes in this guide: "No", "looser", "Your build is shit,you should feel bad" This are no feedbacks or opinions and in my eyes, you should be able to say why you voted the way you did. [quote=BusDriver210] Here is something to chew on. Both your current guides are unorthodox support guides. There is nothing wrong with creating a unorthodox guide, but when I read both of them it only took me about 3 minutes each. They provide very little information beyond what items to buy. On top of that both guides are kind of "walls of text". If you are looking for upvotes and to be a top rated guide you need to put in a great deal more effort. You need to make your guide longer, flow better, and overall look nicer. Compared to the top guides, your guide is lacking in a lot of departments. The best advice I can offer is to continue to work on your guides and make them stand out from the sea of other watered down guides. [/quote] I am not looking for upvote on my guides, even tho i am overworking and updating them at the moment because i got again some spare time (i am at university and only have some room for this every 4 or 5 month). A good flow in a english text is also quite hard for a non-native englishspeaker. I try, but well, it is really, really hard, especially when you do not have to use english all day long. But well, as i said, i am not angry / sad that my guides are no top-tier-guides and i know i have to work a lot to improve them, i am sad when i see a downvote and then the comment like "no" or "looser", this is not the way this "Enable comment to vote" was meant to be... :)[/quote]

[quote=UnicornRage]I think you could report these people, assuming you haven't already. Personally, I believe comment to vote should be 24/7, so you can't avoid providing a reason. Of course, others have already discussed this, saying that the drawbacks would be encouraging more builds to be up voted.[/quote]

[quote=Scrax]Locked. There's already over 9000 threads about this in support, utilize them.[/quote]