The only guides I ever see you criticizing are first-time entries, and you don't have any better a guide than what I have right now...

I guess I would have to say that you are lucky I cannot block comment posts on my guides; you don't deserve to criticize the way you do.

Rubbish guide on countering a single champion. Oh and here you go

You forgot about ONE THING.ONE NECESSARY ITEM ON APC VS CAITLYN. Zhonyia's Hourglass. You can just pop the active when she's using her ult on u.

Screw that indeed, imo. Caitlyn has a low base AS anyways(neglecting the fact that he'll probably only get in range for that by using his ultimate), so relative reduction doesn't have that much effect if she decides to primarily build raw damage for poking. I don't imagine a Caitlyn going all-in against a malphite at all too. If malph gets stomped early game(which he will), he won't be buying that much armor anyways. His shield won't do him any good since Caitlyn can just continually poke him. Either way, malph can't possibly stop Caitlyn from farming while he himself can't get a single minion without getting damaged except for using Seismic Shard. I'm going adc Yi bot, because he scales better with ad than your avarage ranged adc. Why doesn't everyone always play Galio and Malphite while they do scale on resistances? I think I'd rather take Gangplank, Shen or Pantheon against her in top lane. Gangplank can farm from a distance, evading poke and can escape traps easily. Shen has a shield to soak up poke, can farm from a distance and has a gapcloser/taunt to force all-ins and set up ganks. About the same goes for Panth. Perhaps Nidalee might also be a decent pick with her sustain, the gapcloser and burst.

Why is this a caitlyn guide to begin with? The cheat sheet isn't needed in my opinion. Some coding would be nice too I guess. If you fix those points and change your guide a little with the feedback provided(scimitar), I'll definitely upvote this. I do like the concept of creating guides for countering champions. I think one of the best ways of countering Caitlyn is to force all-ins face to face. Her base attack speed isn't great, outdoing her should be possible, especially early game. Traps are perfectly dodge-able in almost any situation, if you play safe.

mastrer, screw that malphite reduces enemy atk speed in an area arround him, and gets additional damage for stacking armor :)

Sounds like a great idea. Cait is a nice girl, she won't be unfair and poke him down from afar without anything he can do about it.

If u want to counter Caitlyn you pick Malphite

This is actualy ********... making a guide how to COUNTER a champion... wtf xD

everyone does, get with the times veng it's like the best strat ever :p but really? scimitar noone ever builds it anyway.

Who buys Mercurial Scimitar JUST to cleanse traps?