bluebehir pretty much said it all

No frozen heart. pointless. you get mana that you dont need.

not bad

The mana is not nice, but the cooldown and slowing enemies attack speed is what i take it for. But, there are more items nice, maybe even better, it`s just that i don`t put on the standard build, than i would not contribute anything.

Nice 1

o.O?

terribad

And for my final thoughts on this discussion:
1. Thornmail is awesome vs another Tryndamere. I get this every time I face Tryn, and that usually wins the game for my team. I have never bought it against a team without Tryn though. I will, if I see three or more hard hitting melee champs on that team.
2. I would never get frozen heart if they have less than three AD champions, but I think one day I'll get it if I'm facing - say - Miss Fortune + Ashe + Riven, or similar. (I'm now tempted - in THAT situation - to take Frozen Heart instead of Thornmail.)
3. I always want to get Entropy or something similar, but I always end up getting Sanguine's plus Infinity Edge plus Phantom Dancer, and I fear I wouldn't finish more than Phage before game end. Having said that - I see most of the value of Entropy comes from Phage anyway.
4. I see situational value in your build, and therefore this guide, but mostly facing melee champions. Personally, I have the most trouble against ranged attackers (be it AD or AP) such as Twitch or Annie, and/or defenders such as Rammus.

Anyway, you've given me more to think about. :)

My brain hurts reading that. It looks like champion A has all the armour and the life leech, and champion B has only a phantom Dancer. I'm sure that isn't what you're working with.

Also, keep in mind that if champion A has 82% to critical strike, it is factually impossible for him to land crits 100% of the time (unless he kills in 3 hits, of course) because the game modifies this chance to reflect true percentage, and not random percentage. In other words, you are much more likely to not crit one time in five than if the numbers were truly random. I hope that makes sense. This was the mod they made to dodge and crit random number generators a while back to "level out" those crazy crit/dodge streaks that make or break you.

Ps. i took into account that 12.000 gold is more realistic than 16.000, so this build is adjusted to the fact that one can actually buy this, As a rule, take 4 items that are below 3000 and you can buy FULL build in dominion.

It gives armor and lowers attack speed of other enemies. I found the hardest opponents other melee carries, so this counters them nicely. Also the cooldown reduction is something i really liked, since i now get to use my ulti a bit more often. The mana is ****, i know, so one might want to argue for Youmoo`s ghostblade, but i just kinda liked the looks on this one.

the guide is ok ,But why Frozen Heart ? it has armor (ok) but mana ??

sry for my english im german