[Read] Hyper's clean-up project

[quote=B-Wong][quote=wRAthoFVuLK] and why can't you just edit the OP instead of reserving 5 posts x_x [/quote] It's more organized.[/quote]

[quote=Adonikam]Fair enough Hyper, I agree some builds shouldn't be high rated.[/quote]

[quote=orochinagi][quote=wRAthoFVuLK] Ok, great, you are going to DV guides you think should be DVed. Everyone should do that, I don't really see the necessity of a thread about it. And what exactly do you have to update us on... the newest bad guides? rofl and why can't you just edit the OP instead of reserving 5 posts x_x [/quote] There's a trully large amount of guides out there... wouldn't be able to fit it all in 1 or 2 posts... 5 is the answer! I see the light now!!!!! And from what I understood, he's not just going to DV guides... he's gonna point out why he's downvoting (which is something most people should do but don't do). Hmmm... back on topic, I agree with Hyper... keeping the guide section clean is a must since it's one of the main things that brings people into this community. Quality > Quantity And regarding the guides that lack updates... having the "patch" information on the guide list would trully be helpful (something like: "updated for patch: 1.0.0.118b")[/quote]

[quote=hypershatter]i am not going to DV any guides. All I am doing is looking at the top guides and discussing whether they should be there, that's all. If they don't, I would recommend an alternative.[/quote]

[quote=orochinagi]If you think a guide is bad, you should downvote and provide constructive comments tho (and explain why you downvoted) :P[/quote]

[quote=The_Nameless_Bard]Largely unupdated, but not archived builds should be removed from high ratings...I don't care how good it was: if it still has [[innervating locket]] or [[zhonya's ring]] or any other now nonexistant items it shouldn't be in the top rated guides... They also desperately need to clean out repeat guides...It's a little horrifying to see the amount of almost identical guides floating around...[/quote]

[quote=Temzilla][quote=The_Nameless_Bard] Largely unupdated, but not archived builds should be removed from high ratings...I don't care how good it was: if it still has [[innervating locket]] or [[zhonya's ring]] or any other now nonexistant items it shouldn't be in the top rated guides... They also desperately need to clean out repeat guides...It's a little horrifying to see the amount of almost identical guides floating around... [/quote] This. You can downvote a build with over 500 up votes all you want, you could make new accounts all day, but the lowest it will get because of how guides are rated is maybe ~60%. Some of the guides that haven't been updated need to be archived automatically or something.[/quote]

[quote=The_Nameless_Bard]Would this work? After a certain amount of not being updated (more than a year) the user who posted it should get a message asking them if they plan to update it and if they say no or don't respond to the message the guide would be archived. Since you can un-archive things on your own it would be reasonable...[/quote]

[quote=Temzilla][quote=The_Nameless_Bard] Would this work? After a certain amount of not being updated (more than a year) the user who posted it should get a message asking them if they plan to update it and if they say no or don't respond to the message the guide would be archived. Since you can un-archive things on your own it would be reasonable... [/quote] Something like that would work.[/quote]

[quote=The_Nameless_Bard]It also sucks to look at several builds for the same champ and have them be identical...[/quote]