[Read] Hyper's clean-up project

[quote=Zeprido]When the database is updated, any champions that are effected by the patch would have their guides put on a queue of sorts and filtered into the outdated list. In the best case scenario, I would probably like to see both an email and a PM sent regarding the individuals guide.[/quote]

[quote=wRAthoFVuLK]ah, that would seem to work well Zep.[/quote]

[quote=Zeprido]Yeah, a similar system could probably be implemented for items (and runes, and masteries of course).[/quote]

[quote=Temzilla][quote=Jebus McAzn] Because at a certain point, the top rated guide (assuming the champion is not new) will begin to accumulate a lot of up votes, even if it does not deserve it. This is the "sheep vote syndrome" that Jun was talking about earlier. [/quote] That, and the way that traffic works, is that people don't look up the lowest rated guides, they will stop at 50% (When the score number stops being green). Also, a lot of people just have no concept of game mechanics, and will start a snowball on guides that are fundamentally flawed for one reason or another. Another reason that i think there should be a "suggest for deletion" button of sorts. (Basically a thing where the mods or whoever would look at the guide and make a judgement upon it.)[/quote]

[quote=wRAthoFVuLK]But I don't trust Scrax's opinion...he is 2bad :( <3[/quote]

[quote=Canoas]I think we need a guideline regarding voting. When should I Up-vote? When should I Down-vote? When should I not vote?[/quote]

[quote=Jebus McAzn][quote=Canoas] I think we need a guideline regarding voting. When should I Up-vote? When should I Down-vote? When should I not vote? [/quote] Few people would read it, and few people who do would be influenced enough by it to actually change their voting methods.[/quote]

[quote=Trojan995][quote=Temzilla] [quote=Jebus McAzn] Because at a certain point, the top rated guide (assuming the champion is not new) will begin to accumulate a lot of up votes, even if it does not deserve it. This is the "sheep vote syndrome" that Jun was talking about earlier. [/quote] That, and the way that traffic works, is that people don't look up the lowest rated guides, they will stop at 50% (When the score number stops being green). Also, a lot of people just have no concept of game mechanics, and will start a snowball on guides that are fundamentally flawed for one reason or another. Another reason that i think there should be a "suggest for deletion" button of sorts. (Basically a thing where the mods or whoever would look at the guide and make a judgement upon it.) [/quote] JunSupport more or less suggested the same thing; instead of having a "veteran recommendation", it's a "see how the vets voted". So vets would just have more influence with their downvotes AND upvotes.[/quote]

[quote=Jebus McAzn]^I would support this. However, if this were to be implemented, it would have to be under an "optional comment-to-vote" system for the vets only. When a veteran votes on a guide, he/she is prompted "Do you want to attach a comment to your vote so other users can see your reasoning?" Then when they click on "See how the veterans voted", a box would drop down saying something like: Jebus McAzn Voted: -1 Reason: Poor item build in general, lack of an explanation in guide. Infinity Edge is much stronger here than Bloodthirster is... etc, etc.[/quote]

[quote=Zeprido][quote=Jebus McAzn] ^I would support this. However, if this were to be implemented, it would have to be under an "optional comment-to-vote" system for the vets only. When a veteran votes on a guide, he/she is prompted "Do you want to attach a comment to your vote so other users can see your reasoning?" Then when they click on "See how the veterans voted", a box would drop down saying something like: Jebus McAzn Voted: -1 Reason: Poor item build in general, lack of an explanation in guide. Infinity Edge is much stronger here than Bloodthirster is... etc, etc. [/quote] I would definitely like to see a combination of this with: [quote=Zeprido] When the database is updated, any champions that are effected by the patch would have their guides put on a queue of sorts and filtered into the outdated list. In the best case scenario, I would probably like to see both an email and a PM sent regarding the individuals guide. [/quote] Would help clean up quite a bit.[/quote]