Thornmail on adc?

[quote=Nebrasketball]If you have 2k health you'll only do around 300-400 damage to the enemy with thornmail. Randuins gives 30 less armor, as/ms slow, health, and a situational active.[/quote]

[quote=Lugignaf]Randuins is better in every regard though. The active helps peel people off you when they jump on you, the health combined with the armor gives more effective health than thornmail, and the passive is just icing in case anyone is trying to kite you.[/quote]

[quote=GrandmasterD][quote=Lugignaf] Randuins is better in every regard though. The active helps peel people off you when they jump on you, the health combined with the armor gives more effective health than thornmail, and the passive is just icing in case anyone is trying to kite you. [/quote] GA, BV and Scimitar all beat Omen imo. Let your team peel for you and get one of those to protect you against the real nasty stuff.[/quote]

[quote=Vynertje][quote=GrandmasterD] [quote=Lugignaf] Randuins is better in every regard though. The active helps peel people off you when they jump on you, the health combined with the armor gives more effective health than thornmail, and the passive is just icing in case anyone is trying to kite you. [/quote] GA, BV and Scimitar all beat Omen imo. Let your team peel for you and get one of those to protect you against the real nasty stuff. [/quote] Overall yes, but not vs a full ad team. Randuins is godlike vs someone like irelia.[/quote]

[quote=Nebrasketball]They are all situational, but I would never buy thornmail on ADC.[/quote]

[quote=GrandmasterD][quote=Vynertje] [quote=GrandmasterD] [quote=Lugignaf] Randuins is better in every regard though. The active helps peel people off you when they jump on you, the health combined with the armor gives more effective health than thornmail, and the passive is just icing in case anyone is trying to kite you. [/quote] GA, BV and Scimitar all beat Omen imo. Let your team peel for you and get one of those to protect you against the real nasty stuff. [/quote] Overall yes, but not vs a full ad team. Randuins is godlike vs someone like irelia. [/quote] Irelia? I'm afraid I do not know that champion.[/quote]

[quote=Pheyniex]All of you are giving bad advice. [[thornmail]] is mandatory on ADC [[Rammus]]. I also remember the golden early S3 days where 4 teammembers could consider buying a [[Randuin's omen]], regardless of who already had one.[/quote]

[quote=NewAthanatov][quote=Mooninites] How about you give us a good reason why a thornmail rush would be good as an ADC? [/quote] Thornmail so the other ADC can't do any damage and the damage he does he gets back so you always win a fight[/quote]

[quote=NewAthanatov]Ok if you guys all think it's bad i won't try it[/quote]

[quote=Meiyjhe]Thornmail rush on ADC to shut down the enemy is a bad idea because: 1. It deals magical damage, ADC's are supposed to deal physical damage 2. It requires the enemy to attack you in order to deal damage, meaning that the enemy ADC can survive battles easier by simply running away, 3. It will not help with farming (really important as ADC) 4. It will not reduce the damage done by magic damage nor it brings back the damage done by spells. So basically, the enemy can poke you to death easily. So no, thornmail rush is not an option :P[/quote]