Hey! Thank you for supporting the guide!

Contrary to what most players expected, I believe Moonstone Renewer is still performing really well with our build this patch. I have been testing the durability patch changes with different builds, and aery/moonstone has given me the best results so far.

Due to the durability changes, I might consider Fimbulwinter as a core item too (works great with Spirit Visage and Moonstone Renewer, you have more time to stack it, extended fights need more mana and the shield can proc more often). The game got slower and there is no need to rush resistances as much as before, so buying only magic resist/armor components and not finishing them until later on seems like the way to go. Try experimenting with Moonstone->Fimbulwinter and see if the playstyle suits you.

Slowing down the game also means longer fights and more time to cycle through your abilities in skirmishes and teamfights - also giving you and your team more value out of Moonstone Renewer than before 12.10 (the main strength of this item is the shielding/healing it provides to your team and longer games mean more of these!).

To be honest, I also expected the W nerf to feel worse, but it does not, due to the longer fights karma excels at.

Grievous wounds have been hit really hard too, which is great for healing builds (for example, based on numbers alone even lifesteal against grievous wounds is stronger than before this patch, even if unreduced healing got weaker).

Overall, the build is in a good spot. I still need to test Sunfire Aegis/Divine Sunderer builds more, but Moonstone Renewer seems very viable and gets more value as the game goes on.

If by relay you mean Rylai's Crystal Scepter, no, I do not. The lack of ability haste makes it not worth an item slot with tank playstyle. The slow is not of use to us either, as your Q and E are enough to chase down or disengage.

Comet is good on mid (mage playstyle), but not so much with our ability haste based tank build. It simply does not provide the insane versatility and teamfight potential aery or phase rush give. Aery can also proc on auto-attacks, which makes your poke better than comet as you want to AA often. Comet is also outperformed by the sustain and scaling of grasp if you want to dominate the lane.

Hey! Not much has changed, but the current prefered build became Moonstone Renewer. I have updated items a bit too.

No hablo bien el español, pero seguro que intentaré probar cosas nuevas. ¡Gracias por el apoyo!

Thank you wholesome person! (And sorry for not replying earlier)

Thanks a lot!

Thanks for the kind words! I will try to update the guide more often after my university exams, so stay tuned!

I definitely want to update it but my time is very limited due to university work, so it may take longer than usual. Sorry for the inconvenience!

Glad to hear that! I would say that depends on your jungler. If you have a lot of spare time (for example if your opponent is passive and you pushed a huge wave, or you do not want to take fights but he freezes) and your jungler is around, it might be a good idea to go for Herald, as you win most 2v2 skirmishes due to the survivability you can provide both to you and to your jungler.

If you want to get better at calls and more comfortable with them, the only thing I can say is: Do not be scared of doing them. Bad calls are good for learning, so call your jungler for that herald, push, or whatever else objective there is to take. You learn more from mistakes than you do from games that go perfectly well - it makes you a better player in the long run!

Thanks, glad you like it! Indeed, her sustainability is unexpected most of the time - and that plays right into our cards.

Thank you so much for your kind words! Glad to hear that you are enjoying your time with my build. I believe Karma is made for top lane, so you definitely made a good choice!

Thanks for the feedback!

I have tried tear several times, not enough times to put it in the guide though. Tear looks good on the paper, yet as it slows the "tank" powerspike, I would take it only occasionally. If you expect to have a long laning phase, especially against opponents that outsustain you, tear can work incredibly well. And it works even better if you have an easy match-up, where the loss of gold does not hurt you as much. Your highest priority should be building the CDR (even more so when The Ultimate Hat was removed and Nimbus Cloak's CD can be reduced) and therefore slowing the core items down might cost you some valuable time to dominate lane-wise.

I will look further into it, test it in different match-ups and we will see how it goes.
But sure, it works, if you already know you have the higher chance to win the lane.