Rate my Signature

[quote=Xiron]Hey there! I want you to rate my signatures. Go ahead! [center] Nocturne Signature [IMG]http://img689.imageshack.us/img689/7140/nocsig2.png[/IMG] Master Yi Signature [IMG]http://img402.imageshack.us/img402/4096/masteryisig1.png[/IMG] Katarina Signature [IMG]http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/1134/katarinasig.png[/IMG] Kog'Maw Signature [IMG]http://img6.imageshack.us/img6/7821/maw.png[/IMG] [/center] If you like them, I could do one for you. Just gimme the Champion and the writings. The default size I'm using for Signatures is 468 x 150 pixel.[/quote]

[quote=wRAthoFVuLK]Not bad, but as said before (the last time you made a thread asking this a few months ago) the effects you used on the Noc one messed it up big time xD The other ones are nice tho, text not bad, but the backgrounds seem random...for instance, with the Kat one...is that a dragon behind her? o-o[/quote]

[quote=Xiron][quote=wRAthoFVuLK] Not bad, but as said before (the last time you made a thread asking this a few months ago) the effects you used on the Noc one messed it up big time xD The other ones are nice tho, text not bad, but the backgrounds seem random...for instance, with the Kat one...is that a dragon behind her? o-o [/quote] I was searching for that Thread. But I didn't find it :-( Sorry 'bout that. Erm... Where are you seeing a dragon?!? I'm afraid![/quote]

[quote=Xiaowiriamu][b]Nocturne Signature[/b] - Nice use of filters - Good composition - Good use of space - Text isn't blended very well * I would recommend using as less text options as possible (bevel, etc.) - Focal point is difficult to determine, my eyes keep being pulled to centre of signature - No lighting Rating: 5/10 [b]Master Yi Signature[/b] - Good text font, very well fitting - Nice background - Lack of composition - Lack of sufficient lighting to enfix focal point - I'm drawn to bottom left of the signature - Master Yi seems too small to even grab any focus * I would recommend setting C4D's to Screen, linear, or color dodge - Text is difficult to read Rating: 4/10 [b]Katarina Signature[/b] - Good background and use of tools - Nice font and style - Katarina too small and not necessarily blended well into the background * I would rcommend color balancing her (Image>Color balance) - Text draws too much of the focal * I would recommend setting C4D's to Screen, linear, or color dodge * I would recommend centering katarina for this type of signature Rating: 4/10 [b]Kog'Maw Signature[/b] - Good concept - Nice font and style * I would recommend lowering the lower opacity one to a bit less opacity. - Good job with pop out - I would recommend blending the C4D in a bit but i seems to fit nicely, however i'll still experiment on whether it looks better with screen, linear or color dodge - Focal point seems decent * I'll recommend sufficient lighting effects Filters>Lighting or using soft brush at low opacity Rating: 6.5/10[/quote]

[quote=wRAthoFVuLK]btw how do you make pop out effects, I never tried it myself. Do you make the canvas and then select the layer to extend the canvas or something? also I think I just saw that C4D on the Kat sig as a dragon, it kinda looks like that xDD[/quote]

[quote=Lugignaf]You might want to shrink your Kog'Maw sig a bit. It's just a smidge too tall for your "needs"[/quote]

[quote=wRAthoFVuLK][quote=wRAthoFVuLK] btw how do you make pop out effects, I never tried it myself. Do you make the canvas and then select the layer to extend the canvas or something? [/quote][/quote]

[quote=Canoas]You just make it a bigger png image with the render sticking out of the box and with it's background transparent. Just an advice, sigs with the pop-out on top do not look good once actually used. I was completely nerdgasming about my sivir sig only to later find that the pop-out was ruining it because it left a big empty space between the actual sig and the post itself. Also, +rep for xiao. Awesome criticism.[/quote]

[quote=wRAthoFVuLK]I have an issue with "nice use of filters" however, on the Nocturne sig criticism xD and wait, what do you mean you make it a bigger png? How do you work with it in photoshop itself? Is the canvas just the box size or do you make it so it can fit the whole thing? o-o[/quote]

[quote=Lugignaf]2 layers. The render is bigger than the background layer. The render's background is removed and transparent. You have your pop-out effect.[/quote]