Commenting on the top 10 in your guide?

[quote=Pølsemanden]Is it in your opinion baad to explain what lacks in the top-10 guides. And implement it in your guide?[/quote]

[quote=Samoh]I take it your referring to criticism, if so no, it's certainly not bad. Telling people what your have learnt, and used (and has proved successful) is certainly not a crime. Although some people don't like it, but most of those people are morons.[/quote]

[quote=jhoijhoi]Depends. If you're doing it solely to badmouth other guides, you're not going to get anywhere. It's best to just write the guide as if you had never seen any of those other guides before.[/quote]

[quote=Pølsemanden]Thing is, of all the top 10 irelia guides, not a single guide utilizes/even mentions a Warmogs, Frozen Mallet and only one a madreds(and that's on the jungle build lolz) none of them get over 4000 hp. And only few get a wits end. Just want to point out in my irelia guide, that my guide does all thoose things :p And i don't do it to badmouth their guide, more like a: Why my guide is better.[/quote]

[quote=Samoh]Oh I see, a why your guide is better? Putting it like that is not a good idea. If you want to criticise in a polite manner, don't say anything like that, it really only makes you look patronising. Just explain to them what you would do differently, and why. Saying what makes their guide worse than yours, also makes you look like you're advertising your guide which just isn't a good idea all together.[/quote]

[quote=Pølsemanden]Can't advertise something not published yet, can i?[/quote]

[quote=jhoijhoi]It's just best not to compare your guide to anyone's. I'd look like a right dick if I compared my Ashe guides to the others and said why mine was better.[/quote]

[quote=TheJohn][quote=Pølsemanden] Thing is, of all the top 10 irelia guides, not a single guide utilizes/even mentions a Warmogs, Frozen Mallet and only one a madreds(and that's on the jungle build lolz) none of them get over 4000 hp. And only few get a wits end. Just want to point out in my irelia guide, that my guide does all thoose things :p And i don't do it to badmouth their guide, more like a: Why my guide is better. [/quote] Im not sure about warmogs, but Frozen Mallet is great on Irelia. Madreds sure helps, but it isnt a must[/quote]

[quote=Pølsemanden]Nothing is ever a must.. Thing is just, that no one in the top 10 has a frozen mallet in their build, some of them mentions it as a situational, but doesn't give a reason about when to get it.. They aren't guiding for shit so to say, just showing and saying herrpa la derrpa. The thing which terrified me the most is the fact that ALL the guides has under 3k hp.. WHAT IS THIS MADNESS!!![/quote]

[quote=Wintermond]Depends.[/quote]