Should all guides be forced to STALE on the S3 roll-out?
Ty MM and Blood for the sigs :3 | Rammus is comming back - heard it here first!
"Carrying"-guide | My reviewservice
"Carrying"-guide | My reviewservice
^It'll be a "soft reset" for MobaFire guides. Authors who only update their guide once every two months will be the only authors hit hard by all their guides being reset to Stale. Regular members will notice their guides as "stale" and will do their best to provide accurate information to the public.
The "go with that" attitude will be downvoted. If the new Utility masteries had a lot of cooldown reduction or something, and I said in my Ashe guide, "NEW UTILITY TREE IS AMAZING, ASHE NEEDS ALL THE COOLDOWN SHE CAN GET", I'd be downvoted, and fairly too.
Minor errors like, maybe picking up a little less AD for survivability, or whatever, isn't going to kill a guide, like you seem to think.
The "go with that" attitude will be downvoted. If the new Utility masteries had a lot of cooldown reduction or something, and I said in my Ashe guide, "NEW UTILITY TREE IS AMAZING, ASHE NEEDS ALL THE COOLDOWN SHE CAN GET", I'd be downvoted, and fairly too.
Minor errors like, maybe picking up a little less AD for survivability, or whatever, isn't going to kill a guide, like you seem to think.
^ It can though. I've seens downvotes before for one questionable item choice.
"Hey that one item isn't great, DV"
Doesn't seem too far of from: "Hey, those new masteries you've selected are sub-par, DV"
I guess if people are planning to DV you anyway, or "would" DV you for that, having "proper" new masteries won't help that much. I see people overreacting in both ways though, so I have no idea what would be best. Either you'd get angry dudes downvoting for outdated masteries, or you'd get downvoted for having new sub-par masteries. Tricky :/
The "normal" people I'm sure wouldn't particularly mind either way, but the guys who are "trolling" would get angry either way.
"Hey that one item isn't great, DV"
Doesn't seem too far of from: "Hey, those new masteries you've selected are sub-par, DV"
I guess if people are planning to DV you anyway, or "would" DV you for that, having "proper" new masteries won't help that much. I see people overreacting in both ways though, so I have no idea what would be best. Either you'd get angry dudes downvoting for outdated masteries, or you'd get downvoted for having new sub-par masteries. Tricky :/
The "normal" people I'm sure wouldn't particularly mind either way, but the guys who are "trolling" would get angry either way.
"Listen to Joe... he knows what he's doing."
People are going to make new guides with the new masteries and update their guides to the new masteries as soon as those masteries are available on MOBAFire, regardless of whether or not they feel like they have to, guys. You can't simply argue that updating immediately is a bad idea and expect that to mean that marking guides stale is a bad idea. No one is arguing that updating guides immediately is a good idea, anyway.
What I don't see either Polse or BarbJ doing is arguing that, a month down the line, it'll be okay for guides to still have the old masteries and still be solidly in top positions.
What I don't see either Polse or BarbJ doing is arguing that, a month down the line, it'll be okay for guides to still have the old masteries and still be solidly in top positions.
OTGBionicArm wrote: Armored wimminz = badass.
My posts may be long. If this bothers you, don't read them.
My posts may be long. If this bothers you, don't read them.
You need to log in before commenting.
I don't think their guide should be shown as updated until they updated the masteries and runes but it's freshness should decay at the usual rate, not instantly.