Rate/Comment Sig

[quote=Symphunny]Well i havent made a sig or anything like that for a long time, probably a year. So yesterday, i wanted to make a sig for myself. I looked at a few tuts on deviantart and checked out some pro sig on mobafire forums and i got to making my sig.... The result, imo was not bad. If you guys can rate/criticize, id appreciate it. [img]http://i56.tinypic.com/nch7qe.jpg[/img] EDIT: i uploaded it in .png now[/quote]

[quote=Alexanpt]Simple. You added the text and that border at the right. But I think it's nice tho. There are many sites who have good tuts how to make sigs, you should check them out. ^ ^- I started at sigtutorials.com At first is a bit difficult but it gets easier. Trust me. =) Nice simple job ^^[/quote]

[quote=Canoas]Incredibly bad quality. There's nothing to improve if you're going to upload it with the worst quality possible. 0/10[/quote]

[quote=wRAthoFVuLK]omg you don't have to be so rude Canoas...xD but yea he's right :P upload it in png.[/quote]

[quote=Nighthawk]doesnt actually look that bad to me. Although it could obviously be better, try adding some effects etc.[/quote]

[quote=Canoas]I was not rude, I was blunt. There's a difference. And I know I don't have to be, I was because I wanted to.[/quote]

[quote=wRAthoFVuLK]lol Canoas xD question: what up with the random white line going down the sig? o_O[/quote]

[quote=Alexanpt]Not that bad... dont be like that, dude. It's simple. Very simple, I'm a simpleton, yeah. It doesn't look that bad in quality.[/quote]

[quote=Bloofyre]Yeah that sectioning off border/line seems a bit out of place. Now obviously I don't make sings, but I do know a thing or two about graphical appearances and what I think you could improve on. First off, that line does not flow with the overall feeling of the sig, it is more of an eyesore than anything. If you do want to section it off, try a slightly thinner black line, or a strip of transparency where that white line is. Also, I have to agree with everyone else, it is a bit grainy, and I am not 100% sure what you can do about that, I guess listen to wRAth and upload in .png next time will (slightly) solve that? Try that to start and then you may have something here.[/quote]

[quote=Symphunny]thanks guys for the criticism, but its not that simple. here it is without all the effects except for that fail white line [img]http://i55.tinypic.com/352qipw.jpg[/img] outcome [img]http://i56.tinypic.com/nch7qe.jpg[/img] im sure youll see some effects and i was satisfied with the result so i didnt add any C4Ds and ruin it... well ill get better eventually ^ ^[/quote]