Did you win the game?
If yes, good tank.
If no, bad tank.
Lol, but no, seriously. Assists are generally the best sign that you've been tanking properly. Did your carries get a pile of kills? Did they die frequently? Were you winning teamfights? Did you make an utter mess of their team structure?
These are questions to ask. Your job as a tank is not exactly shown by the final score of the game. It's how you played for the team. Did you taunt the Caitlyn every fight? Did you silence the Brand? Those are things to keep in mind.
Final scores, you can look at your deaths versus the rest of the team's deaths. If you died more then the rest of your team combined, you were probably holding focus and keeping your team alive. The exception is obviously if you died incredibly frequently, but that goes without saying, I think.
If yes, good tank.
If no, bad tank.
Lol, but no, seriously. Assists are generally the best sign that you've been tanking properly. Did your carries get a pile of kills? Did they die frequently? Were you winning teamfights? Did you make an utter mess of their team structure?
These are questions to ask. Your job as a tank is not exactly shown by the final score of the game. It's how you played for the team. Did you taunt the Caitlyn every fight? Did you silence the Brand? Those are things to keep in mind.
Final scores, you can look at your deaths versus the rest of the team's deaths. If you died more then the rest of your team combined, you were probably holding focus and keeping your team alive. The exception is obviously if you died incredibly frequently, but that goes without saying, I think.

Thanks for your input, I like to keep a lot of those things in mind. Ultimately, I think that you can't measure the tank's effectiveness by looking at deaths, assists, or kills. Really you have to measure yourself with questions like:
Did my carries get a lot of kills without dying very much?
Did I take the amount of damage necessary to give my carries the kills?
Did I intervene at the right time to save Teemo, or was my sacrifice unnecessary?
That is why a lot of people don't believe what a good tank can do until they play with one.
Did my carries get a lot of kills without dying very much?
Did I take the amount of damage necessary to give my carries the kills?
Did I intervene at the right time to save Teemo, or was my sacrifice unnecessary?
That is why a lot of people don't believe what a good tank can do until they play with one.
Beeswarm17 wrote:
Did you win the game?
If yes, good tank.
If no, bad tank.
Legit.
I was going to write this.

http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/duffs-336706
Come hang out when I'm streaming! http://www.twitch.tv/dufftime
kmododragonNM wrote:
Did my carries get a lot of kills without dying very much?
Did I take the amount of damage necessary to give my carries the kills?
Did I intervene at the right time to save Teemo, or was my sacrifice unnecessary?
No.
Kills don't mean anything.
You either win, or you lose, the score could be 505 kills for your team to 10 deaths, and if their shaco back doors you once effectively and kills your nexus, you still lost.
Measure your effectiveness in how often you make the winning initiation in a teamfight. How often you soak most of their cooldowns and your team can mop up - without thinking about the kills, just thinking about why the damage on your team was more effectively distributed.
Are you tanky enough to take big hits from the enemy DPS'ers? Things like that.

http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/duffs-336706
Come hang out when I'm streaming! http://www.twitch.tv/dufftime
yeah, pretty much what everyone else said. My last game as Leona went 3-4-25 and we won, so, I did my job. Problem is, no one usually appreciates it especially in solo...but that doesn't matter. You KNOW when you've ****ing tanked well, and you don't need the acknowledgement from your team.
:)
:)

i make it a policy to compliment every support for a nice heal/save or any tank on exceptional tanking...but that doesn't apply to most of the general public. In solo, the compliments i receive as support or tank are usually nonexistent, of course in a premade that changes since we try and motivate each other, which you should do at all costs. Still, i gain great satisfaction everytime i save someone's *** with that last "wish" cast or on an initiate which aces the enemy team at best even at the expense of my own death. 2 turrets for 1 death is always worth it.

You need to log in before commenting.
So I would like to pose this question to other tank players: what do you base your score on at the end of the game? How do you usually measure how well you've played? Hopefully I get some solutions that can help me better judge the quality of my play.