1)Got nerfed, the information you are showing is outdated.
2)Ad carry gets caught in a malphite ult -> (if teams is smart) everybody throws everything at ad carry and he will probably get chain CC'ed what will the extra 400 hp (took the difference between vayne and corki) help with ? Really, a smart ad carry shall never get caught in a malphite ultimate and malphite will be able to punish heavily every ad carry in bad position, vayne is not the only one, this doesn't mean you pick no ad carry when you see malphite on enemy team, right?
3)True, vayne gets outpushed by most ad carries, but last hiting with her under turret is not that hard cause of auto attack reset, of course you must have alot of practice to last hit under turret too
4)I see that you want your guide be the #1? Then why should I not compare it with the #1 rated one? My logic: why make a guide for a champion that has a decent one already when mobafire has alot of champions with trash guides (skarner example). If you think that the current #1 rated one misses on something then tell me what, I surely can't see this "Missing Information" in your guide.

I am in no way trying to pick on you, I just think that making this guide, which brings nothing new (if it does excuse my inablity to find it and point it out), doesn't have any use.

I already stated that people could put Butcher somewhere else if they didnt want it. I'll take the points out of magic resist and put it into Executioner .


Perhaps I should have gone more in depth with the items... Usually, I buy some Dagger's and then go for a B.F. Sword and then a Phantom Dancer. Thanks for you suggestions, I'll go more in depth with Phantom Dancer and Bloodthirster.

Take one point out of Butcher and replace it with in Sunder . Take 3 out of the magic resist and put it to get Executioner . So much better overall

Getting Bloodthirster before Phantom Dancer is alot better because it allows you trade more efficently(Not saying you should try),allows you to constantly 1 hit minions under tower(2 hit melee 1 hit range from tower). Also the sustain allows you to withstand harass.

1) Really? when I go to champions info in League Of Legends and select Vayne, It says she gains quadruple movement speed.

2) Do you even know anything at all about Vayne? She has the lowest base-health of all AD Carries. And no, Vayne gets bursted alot easier than any other AD Carry.

3) you know... when playing in lane with Vayne you almost always get pushed to turret, and you can't have enough AD to lasthit with when that happens, so Butcher helps farming at tower.
''Probably I'd find more things like this if I'd keep reading it but I am a bit tired.'' 1 comment:
Did I not tell you in the INTRODUCTION to read ALL OF THE GUIDE THROUGH BEFORE CRITICIZING?

4) This guide was released about 2 hours ago. Who knows, maybe it will get rated better than the top Vayne guide? You just can't judge the quality of my guide by COMPARING it with other guides made by famous mobafire users who gets alot of views because they're famous. I've read jhoijhoi's Vayne guide but it does miss quite some things.

You sound like you just want to pick on me, but I respect you for atleast pointing some things out. But I am REALLY mad that you didn't read that you have to read all the guide through before criticizing.

Your Cheat Sheet is incomplete, you can add 1 more item.

There is no real reason for taking 18-12-0, I personally run 16-13-1 or something like that, taking Tough Skin and Indomitable for better trades during laning phase. I also upgrade Ignite and Flash, but since you take Cleanse it's obviously great if you upgrade that. There is no real need for Resistance , imo.

Taking ArPen Marks and/or Quints is fine as well :)

In your masteries section you explain something different than what it says on your cheat sheet :P Also the third sentence is really weird, you might want to look into that.

You should do a better job at explaining her skills - you just literally copied what the tooltip also states. Give some useful tips (like: Use Tumble to position yourself in such a way you can use Condemn to let your enemy hit a wall and get stunned) instead.

Your core build should include Berserker's Greaves and Bloodthirster. And you mean buff and not debuff from Nunu & Willump :P

Coding error at the end of Situational Items.

Vayne actually does pretty well with aggressive supports like Blitzcrank and Sona as well. Because of their CC she has an easy time Condemning people into terrain, often granting kills.

That's about it. Pretty okay guide overall but you need to focus especially on the contents. Ratings for now:

Appearance: 6/10
Cheat Sheet: 8/10
Contents: 5/10

An overall 6,3, gratz on my upvote ;)

I think you mean triple.


I there a kind of tank ad carry that wont get bursted down if caught in that position? This is the general risk of playing ad carry, not only vayne.

You already have Ad marks and quints, how much more help you need with last hiting? ( butcher mastery)

Probably I'd find more things like this if I'd keep reading it but I am a bit tired.

I'd say this guide doesnt have an edge over the others, why would I not choose the #1 rated vayne guide over yours? I don't see that reason therefore I don't think this deserves an upvote.

Yeah, I've had a LOT of problems with trollvoters in both my Ezreal and Vladimir Guide, but I thought people would hate me for taking it on. For the sake of your judgement I have instructed people to put a point in Sunder instead of Summoner's Resolve when using Cleanse. Anyways, thanks for your feedback, and thanks for upvoting!

Well built! Some words of advice- require comment to vote makes better ratings, reduces troll votes AND gives better feedback. I would drop off the point in Summoner's Resolve . Keep it if you use Heal, but with Cleanse it's not as effective as another point in Sunder will be imo. Overall, excellent work!