Hi there,

ive looked into your guide.. Ow dear, you have more homework than i have! ;-3

1. you got to finish & update your guide for S3. Some items are not there anymore, e.g. Force of Nature!

2. Cheatsheet: Seems unfinished. Im missing a lot more viable (offense/defense) items for Garen (e.g. Infinity Edge, Black Cleaver, Sunfire Cape, Runic Bulwark, Guardian Angel aso). And some of your choices are strange! Bilgewater Cutlass/Blade of the Ruined King for Garen? Why? Absolutely poor synergy with his skills. Garen needs Attack Damage, Armor Penetration, Critical Chance in an offense item. Trinity Force to end off? Better take Infinity Edge for about the same price for more damage and crit chance. There is also no Final Build Example. But indirectly i can see it from the "Core" (which actually is a purchase of order, but not a care sheet) and "End off":
Boots of Swiftness Blade of the Ruined King Warmog's Armor Randuin's Omen Frozen Mallet Trinity Force
Well, if this is your recommended build, i would replace the BotRK with Black Cleaver and TF with Infinity Edge, then it is fine.

3. Content. Very little explanations. Poor formatting. No ornaments, no pics. Looks very unattractive. You started some chaps, but infinished with "Coming Soons" promises. Its about over a month, still nothing changed. Do you still work on that guide???

4. Conclusion: A very unfinished guide. Why did you even publish it, if its still in an Alpha.Version?? You are provoking people to downvote you.

Since im hoping to see a final version, im not voting yet.

Good Luck!

This says it all.

Thy sins
1. No example build
2. Maybe some might like it, but I dislike using the egg for pros and revive for cons, something more Garenly would be more appropriate :D
3. Everything is minimal explained
4. I dislike your use of structure
5. Why do you explain summoner spells after you explained your items?
6. Force of Nature does not exist anymore, yet he remains in your guide.
7. And please remove the outdated summoner spells aswell
8. Lane synergy is fun and all, but pretty useless, besides, it remains unexplained.
9. You said in your guide 2 times: Coming soon. The guide exists since october 2012
10. I can count the pixels in the last picture

Thy blessing
1. Comment to vote was on
2. Decent structure in the cheatsheet
3. Decent build
4. Decent use of coding
5. All basics included

Result: Path of Redemption
Come on man, you need to do better than this.
Remove the stuff that is outdated, explain your choices with a bit more depth and fix your structure, because it is really weird to look at, especially in your Runes, Boots and Summoner spell chapters (The summoner spell one is just too big)

A lot of stuff you can work on,
Have fun :D

(Do not forget to vote! :D)

Hahah i used to, and the botrk was buffed then nerfed, so now im stuck between cleaver/botrk ._.

great guide man Garren may be kinda weak right now but people must remember riot just "retooled" (nerfed) him he is still fun to play all I really had to add was consider Movement Quins an alternate those combined with boots of swiftness and Garren's Q =) some scary stuff right there you can always buy Last Whisper or Black Cleaver for extra armor pen

Ikr? I need to get rid of some of this ****ty stuff. I always find an excuse not to though.

I like some parts of this guide, but this really needs a good makeover.
The Season 2 stuff really needs to go. A little more explanation in terms of runes and masteries would be nice.
Not bad though.

~GL

You didnt read it did you... *sigh SIMPLICITY PEOPLE READ THE GAWD DAMN BUILD NAEMEEEEE!!!*

I dont think starting with Doran's Blade is a good idea, and i think there are more better items for Garen what could replace Frozen Mallet:s by the way the guide is very nice:)