Being a bad guide writer doesn't stop you from being part of the community.

Look at the higher rated guides. Look at what they have and you don't. They are well formatted, clear and concise. It makes it so that anyone new to the game can understand why they have done what they have done on champion x.

You should have taken a look at the Beginner's Guide to Making a Guide. As a successful guide writer, you must cater to your audience's needs. By writing meager amounts, you teach new players nothing and show all players none of what you may know.

This is my feedback:
The guide is too short. If you wanted to share your way of playing vi you could've made a thread called "How i play vi" or posted on one regarding vi.
A guide is what the name suggests, an in-depth walkthrough that teaches someone how to play a champ.
This doesn't meet the mobafire guide standards, and that is why it's getting a lot of criticism.
As i said, you probably should have made a thread about this instead of a guide c:

im a 30 gold division one...thanks for just taking my guide terribly. i wanted feedback not criticism...thanks guys. really makes me even want to try to be apart of the community...

A meager amount of 10% Critical Strike Chance provided by this build (by mid game), and yet 3 Mastery points wasted in Frenzy and Lethality.

What you do is play against lv 17 players. Tried and tested? You don't even qualify for the trying part.

And i told you in the guide why i got the items i did. There should be a cheat sheet section where you just share what items to get and a brief description. Why does there have to be an essay going along with it?

See idc about the lore or the writing or walkthrough or whatever. Im not trying to teach you guys how to play a champ. Just give you advice and what I do. Why do these guides have to be so complicated. I just wanted to share what i do and i didnt wanna write a whole essay on it. Period. Just wanted to share.

Agreed 100%

People really need to learn how to make a guide before trying to make a guide, if they want it to be successful in any way whatsoever.

No bb coding, remove the lore, all sections are too short, and the guide as a whole is short even if you had longer sections. -1 based on all of that. I am not even going to look at the cheatsheet. Justify your choices and then I might take a look at the cheatsheet.