OTG's Review Station

[quote=OTGBionicArm]Hello, all. I'm OTGBionicArm, and once again I am offering my services as a guide reviewer. It's simple and easy, just fill out this form in a comment; Summoner Name/Level: Champion: Intended Role: Guide Link: I will be grading the guide based on the following factors (keep in mind I will actually PLAY the champion using YOUR guide before writing my review): Cheat Sheet: How clean it is, item paths/runes/masteries, how thorough it is. 1-10 points. Legibility: How easy is the guide to read? Am I bored out of my mind? Is any of this information actually helpful? Could I have easily looked this up on the League wiki? Did I learn to play the champion as intended by the writer? 1-10 points. Creativity: Is this build unique is some way? Is the playstyle unique? Does it actually work? I give bonus points for off-meta things if you truly convince me that it works (IE; support [[mordekaiser]] probably will not fly, but AD [[Orianna]] might.) 1-10 points, 1-5 bonus points if your off-meta build convinces me it works. Formatting and prettiness: I like nice looking guides. 1-5 points. Attitude: I will grade you based on how you respond to other users feedback as well. Accepting feedback and looking to fix mistakes is a very big part of being a guide writer. 1-10 points. Be aware that I'm obviously not amazing at every champion so I'll list the champions I am already decent/proficient with in each role; Top: [[aatrox]], [[Cho'Gath]], [[Darius]], [[Gangplank]], [[Garen]], [[Jarvan IV]], [[nidalee]], [[Quinn]], [[Rengar]], [[Shen]], [[Trundle]], [[Warwick]], [[Wukong]], [[Zac]] Mid: [[Brand]], [[Cho'Gath]], [[Galio]], [[jayce]], [[Kayle]], [[Kha'zix]], [[Morgana]], [[Swain]], [[Talon]], [[varus]], [[Viktor]], [[Ziggs]] ADC: [[Draven]], [[Graves]], [[Lucian]], [[varus]] Jungle: [[amumu]], [[Cho'Gath]], [[hecarim]], [[nasus]], [[Sejuani]], [[Volibear]], [[Warwick]] Support: [[Sona]], [[taric]], [[thresh]] I will put higher scrutiny on guides for these champions as I actually play them regularly. Everything else will be a learning experience for me. Anyway, that's all, let the reviews come in. :3 EDIT: I can only do one review per day, due to the time consuming way I choose to do reviews. This is to ensure quality reviews. Sorry if you have to wait. :c[/quote]

[quote=jhoijhoi]+1 for actually attempting what the cheat sheet claims first before critiquing :)[/quote]

[quote=OTGBionicArm]Thanks jhoi. I feel you can't really judge a guide until you actually try it, as written.[/quote]

[quote=jhoijhoi]Suggestion though, maybe order your champions through the roles Riot uses? Marksman etc? Then you won't get so much double-up.[/quote]

[quote=OTGBionicArm]I don't play certain champions in their intended roles. I won't say I'm good at Marksman [[Quinn]] when I actually play her top lane and more like an assassin or bruiser. I guess I should make that distinction, but it matters little to the reviews.[/quote]

[quote=Janitsu]Summoner Name/Level: Junatsee 30 Champion: [[Sat...]] - [[TEEMO]]! Intended Role: Top Guide Link: http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/teemos-code-336848 here ya go sili boi<3 [quote=otgbionicarm] I will be grading the guide based on the following factors (keep in mind I will actually PLAY the champion using YOUR guide before writing my review):[/quote] [h5]AWWWW YISSSS[/H5][/quote]

[quote=OTGBionicArm][s]Ah shit. I don goof'd.[/s] Will have it done first chance I can tomorrow![/quote]

[quote=OTGBionicArm]First review completed.[/quote]

[quote=Vynertje]Oh I'm definitely going to make use of this when I release my [[irelia]] guide soon :D[/quote]

[quote=XeresAce]Summoner name/level: XeresAce, lvl 30 Champion: [[Lissandra]] Intended role: Ap carry, mid. [url = http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/do-the-iceborn-dream-of-frozen-sheep-ap-mid-lissandra-guide-340779]Link to the guide.[/url] Because why not[/quote]