<◄•►> Sir Wellington's Review Shop...

[quote=Sir Wellington][center][size=7][color=darkorange][u]The shop has been closed.[/u][/color][/size] [/center] [rule] [columns] [nextcol width=400][center][size=5][color=darkorange][u]About this Review Shop[/u][/color][/size][/center] The purpose of this review shop is to give you direction and advice on how to improve your guide. I promise to fully review and give constructive feedback on every guide posted here. You'll get the most out of my reviews if you use them to improve your guide by addressing the problems I list in it (re-reviews are welcome!) [nextcol width=100] [nextcol width=400][center][size=5][color=darkorange][u]About Sir Wellington[/u][/color][/size][/center] I'm a Gold V NA server Xin Zhao main who started playing way back in December 2011. I've been around the block enough times to have a deep knowledge of the game, how it works, what's viable, and what's not viable. I'm also a little obsessive about organization, so I value clean coding, formatting, and presentation quite a lot.[/columns] [columns] [nextcol width=400][center][size=5][color=darkorange][u]What's in a review?[/u][/color][/size][/center] My reviews will break down the guide from start to finish. They will match the level of work needed to make the guide great. If a lot of work is needed, it'll be a long (but very helpful) review. If you just need some touchups here and there, it'll be short and concise. I'll grade your guide on a scale of 1-5, with 1 being awful and 5 being awesome. I will never use abusive or demeaning language in my reviews. [nextcol width=100] [nextcol width=400][center][size=5][color=darkorange][u]Ask me for a review if...[/u][/color][/size][/center] [list] [*] You want help formatting/coding [*] You want constructive criticism [*] You want help with grammar/spelling [*] You're willing to improve your guide [*] You want an upvote (if it's worthy) [/list][/columns] [columns][nextcol width=200][nextcol width=500][table] [tr] [th padding=5 bgcolor=444 colspan=3]Review Scaling[/th] [/tr] [tr] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Score[/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Description[/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Result[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444][center][size=5][color=white][b]1[/b][/color][/size][/center][/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Awful. Your guide needs a mountain of work before it's worth reading (but it also makes the review much more useful).[/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Downvote[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444][center][size=5][color=lawngreen][b]2[/b][/color][/size][/center][/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Weak. Your guide's potential is overshadowed by its glaring problems. With a good deal of work, you can definitely turn it around.[/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444][center]-[/center][/td] [/tr] [tr] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444][center][size=5][color=cornflowerblue][b]3[/b][/color][/size][/center][/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Good. Your guide is solid. It's definitely not perfect, but it delivers all the necessary information and covers the basics.[/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444][center]-[/center][/td] [/tr] [tr] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444][center][size=5][color=#800080][b]4[/b][/color][/size][/center][/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Excellent. Your guide is as polished as it is rare. Only a few minor problems hold it back from being perfect.[/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Upvote[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444][center][size=5][color=darkorange][b]5[/b][/color][/size][/center][/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]AWESOME! Your guide is a model for other guides. It goes far above and beyond teaching the basics, and its artwork and coding are top notch.[/td] [td padding=5 bgcolor=444]Upvote, +rep[/td] [/tr] [/table] [nextcol width=200][/columns] [columns][nextcol width=400][center][size=5][color=darkorange][u]Proper Format for a Request[/u][/color][/size][/center] 1. Have a [u]COMPLETED[/u] guide that you've published. I cannot review an unpublished guide and I will not review a guide that doesn't have the bare bones at least. If you're planning on adding lots of stuff later, but your guide functions as is, I'll review it. 2. Put a request in a comment below. I need a link to the guide and any special notes (if necessary), like "Artwork coming soon™" or "I just need help coding this particular section". Otherwise I'll review the whole thing and assume it's completed. 3. Sit back and relax :) I'll be checking this daily over the summer, so expect to have your review within a few days. If there's a waitlist, it might take longer but I will still get to it. 4. Please acknowledge in some way that you've read my review. Commenting on it in your guide discussion, replying to this thread, or pming me all work. [nextcol width=100] [nextcol width=400] [center][size=5][color=darkorange][u]My reviews are free.[/u][/color][/size][/center] I don't require any compensation for a review. They do take a long time to write, so if you're feeling charitable, any +reps or feedback on my own guide would be much appreciated: [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/pre-s6-be-a-man-a-manly-xin-zhao-guide-for-top-lane-414086][img]https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/z5Q3id8SfxkxeBijqtz-Pmg_ABO-M-YYNIGPTKUWlnc=w1600-h900-rw[/img][/url][/quote]

[quote=GrandmasterD][img=https://i.imgur.com/f0jTBvk.gif][/quote]

[quote=TheSilverDust]How come that 1-awesome and 5-awful doesn't match to the table which is 1-awful & 5-awesome? That will cause confusion to the people who would like to have their guide be reviewed. Just askin', thanks. :^3[/quote]

[quote=Re4XN]May I be your first customer, kind sir? :D Here's my guide: [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/mundo-how-to-go-where-you-please-pre-season-6-423329] Dr. Mundo Guide[/url] I just finished updating it for patch 5.22[/quote]

[quote=Sir Wellington][quote=TheSilverDust]How come that 1-awesome and 5-awful doesn't match to the table which is 1-awful & 5-awesome? That will cause confusion to the people who would like to have their guide be reviewed. Just askin', thanks. :^3[/quote] [img]http://www.quickmeme.com/img/9e/9e31fa0d1b9c49d0686c2044b35a3e69493a3038697738b0a7139923c0ccb61d.jpg[/img][/quote]

[quote=Sir Wellington][quote=Re4XN]May I be your first customer, kind sir? :D Here's my guide: [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/mundo-how-to-go-where-you-please-pre-season-6-423329] Dr. Mundo Guide[/url] I just finished updating it for patch 5.22[/quote] Done![/quote]

[quote=Padrepio]That's my guide [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/preseason-6-in-depth-brand-catching-fire-443349]Brand-Catching fire[/url]. I'd like to have an honest review from you :)[/quote]

[quote=chinarp]I would really enjoy a review on my [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/5-22-in-progress-a-master-class-on-how-to-play-draaaaven-435359]Draven Guide[/url]. I am not finished with my S6 Item changes, but they will be added soon![/quote]

[quote=Sir Wellington][quote=chinarp]I would really enjoy a review on my [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/5-22-in-progress-a-master-class-on-how-to-play-draaaaven-435359]Draven Guide[/url]. I am not finished with my S6 Item changes, but they will be added soon![/quote] Finals are making my schedule crazy for the next week or so, but I'll review your guide as soon as I get the opportunity.[/quote]

[quote=GeoenerG]My [[ekko]] guide link is down below: [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/time-is-on-your-side-4-in-1-ekko-builds-guide-5-24-431237]Ekko guide link[/url] I would apppreciate anything really.[/quote]