Dorans Shield or Cloth Armor ?

[quote=Insomaniac]Hi guys ! I new here and doesn't really know how to code yet .. Just wanna ask you a newbie question .. When is the time that you would go for a Dorans Shield rather than a Cloth Armor against an AD Top ?[/quote]

[quote=Joxuu](Correct me if I'm wrong guys) but I think Doran's shield is better when you can fight equalliy and seek for trades/fights. Cloth armor start is to outsustain the enemy.[/quote]

[quote=PsiGuard]I wouldn't go [[doran's shield]] against AD top laners ([[cloth armor]] gives more pots and is way safer). You could consider shield if you take [[teleport]] and/or are up against someone who doesn't deal much physical damage outside autoattacks or doesn't have a great all-in. Doran's Shield is a fairly cost-efficient item for early survivability but it doesn't give enough sustain to warrant starting with imo unless you're not too worried about getting harassed out of lane.[/quote]

[quote=KatariFIRE]Take [[Doran's Shield]] or [[Doran's Blade]] if you play an aggressive champions that will trade a lot. like [[Jax]], [[Renekton]], [[Darius]]. If you are an underdog take [[Cloth Armor]] with x 3 [[healing potion]]. like [[Mundo]], [[Urgot]], [[Singed]].[/quote]

[quote=sirell][quote=KatariFIRE] If you are an underdog take [[Cloth Armor]] with x 3 [[healing potion]]. like [[Mundo]], [[Urgot]], [[Singed]].[/quote] 5 health pots. Some champions can also start [[crystalline flask]] + 3 potions.[/quote]

[quote=Insomaniac]Thanks for the answers guys .. BTW .. I like to play Jax Top but having difficulties against a Renekton .. What first items would you suggest ? Cloth Armor + Pots ? Or Flask + Pots ?[/quote]