How do you feel about dividing tournaments based on tier?
GrandmasterD wrote:
Pretty much. Also, isn't a tournament about deciding who is better? Why would you purposely exclude better people from it?
thank god someone else here can see the logical side
anyway, I'm posting a blog about this and another topic because this idea just pissed me off so much

Thanks for the Signature MissMaw!
Mooninites wrote:
thank god someone else here can see the logical side
anyway, I'm posting a blog about this and another topic because this idea just pissed me off so much
Could use something to read now so I'll await teh blog.

GrandmasterD wrote:
Pretty much. Also, isn't a tournament about deciding who is better? Why would you purposely exclude better people from it?
Read this:
http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/forum/mobafire-support/really-gonna-let-this-happen-tournament-22257
Having pro teams join the tournament just because of the prizes wasn't exactly ideal either.
Wayne3100 wrote:
Read this:
http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/forum/mobafire-support/really-gonna-let-this-happen-tournament-22257
Having pro teams join the tournament just because of the prizes wasn't exactly ideal either.
It's not ideal but you cannot exclude people because they are good. And how are you gonna draw the line huh? Individual skill? What if people just use smurfs then? Diamond people will complain about Challenger players. Platinum will complain about Diamond, etc. And there won't be nearly enough players to get a decent competition going in the higher ladders. That is, if you make separate tournaments.

MobaFire tournaments are meant to be amateur. You don't see pee-wee soccer kids playing against David Beckham. It's the same idea here.
jhoijhoi wrote:
MobaFire tournaments are meant to be amateur. You don't see pee-wee soccer kids playing against David Beckham. It's the same idea here.
Then what's the line? Platinum? Can I join then because I'm Gold now? It's a tournament of MOBAFire and the rules state that if you're a member that you can join not that you have to be an amateur. It'd be ridiculous to say no to certain individuals because they are good. If David Beckham would be allowed to play with the pee-wee soccer kids, he could compete against them too. He just can't play with them because of his age, not because of his skill.

@ GMD
I wasn't trying to say I agree with the decision that was made, I simply answered your question as to why people would be excluded to begin with.
Some of the things you mentioned (such as using smurfs) have been discussed in that thread or others about the same topic though.
I wasn't trying to say I agree with the decision that was made, I simply answered your question as to why people would be excluded to begin with.
Some of the things you mentioned (such as using smurfs) have been discussed in that thread or others about the same topic though.
You need to log in before commenting.
<Veteran>