Name: RosePhoenix
Link to your guide :"Reverent riven, an indepth riven guide by rose phoenix"
Ah... A guide which I actually get good vibes from the moment I start reading.
You spent 20 hours on your guide? It shows. I spent days on mine. It shows.
Ok, I lied a bit. There's already a small hiccup. AFAIK - Riven has dashes - not blinks. You can blink through an
Event Horizon without being stunned, dashing will result in you being stunned.
I'm not going to do this in the normal format because I actually like this guide for the most part. It's got next to no spelling errors, grammatically well-done, informative and relevant. It's just incomplete
So instead, i'll go through this section by section, because this guide didn't induce rage, and has the potential to go far. So it seems logical to me to put this into a new format.
Masteries:
1-
Summoner's Wrath
doesn't boost ignite...
2- Why not 3 in
Hardiness
and 1 in
Tough Skin
?
3- No flexibility. Would you really take
Hardiness
against
Vladimir for example?
Runes:
I dont see why flat arpen marks would be better the more AD you have. IT's flat. -12 is -12, 80 or 120 ad.
Glyphs: You want scaling MR glyphs if against AD laners. OMG YOU EXPLAINED. BRB BUYING LOTTERY TICKET. But in all seriousness, why not any others, like say, CDR?
No other exceptions implies there's an exception somewhere. If there aren't any, it's just "no exceptions"
Summoner spells:
Mentioning
Ignite cuts down healing seems something awfully obvious to miss out, especially since you mention it later.
Skillset:
A little wall-o-texty. Put in paragraphs.
Honestly. That's all i can say about this. It's got tips, it's got good knowledge. Points in your favour.
Skill sequence:
OMG EXPLANATIONS.
No comment. More points.
Items:
You say start boots and x4 potions. Yet you only talk about 3 in the actual explanation.
You state what you get and why, but you don't state what you don't get and why. I.e,
Frozen Mallet,
Warmog's Armor. Yes I know it's generally a daft idea on Riven, but it's still something people would be interested in.
Playstyles:
Not. blinks.
Skill combinations:
Good.
Early game, mid game, late game:
Fine.
Conclusions:
I'll be watching this guide. It shows potential.
The thing it's desperately missing at the moment to me would be lane-match ups.
When that's done, assuming it's to the same standard as the rest of the guide, will easily result in a +1 from me.
But since it isn't complete at the moment, i'm rating it Ok.
As much as I would love to upvote it, it's a principle of mine to not really vote on incomplete guides.
Link to your guide :"Reverent riven, an indepth riven guide by rose phoenix"
Ah... A guide which I actually get good vibes from the moment I start reading.
You spent 20 hours on your guide? It shows. I spent days on mine. It shows.
Ok, I lied a bit. There's already a small hiccup. AFAIK - Riven has dashes - not blinks. You can blink through an

I'm not going to do this in the normal format because I actually like this guide for the most part. It's got next to no spelling errors, grammatically well-done, informative and relevant. It's just incomplete
So instead, i'll go through this section by section, because this guide didn't induce rage, and has the potential to go far. So it seems logical to me to put this into a new format.
Masteries:
1-

2- Why not 3 in


3- No flexibility. Would you really take


Runes:
I dont see why flat arpen marks would be better the more AD you have. IT's flat. -12 is -12, 80 or 120 ad.
Glyphs: You want scaling MR glyphs if against AD laners. OMG YOU EXPLAINED. BRB BUYING LOTTERY TICKET. But in all seriousness, why not any others, like say, CDR?
No other exceptions implies there's an exception somewhere. If there aren't any, it's just "no exceptions"
Summoner spells:
Mentioning

Skillset:
A little wall-o-texty. Put in paragraphs.
Honestly. That's all i can say about this. It's got tips, it's got good knowledge. Points in your favour.
Skill sequence:
OMG EXPLANATIONS.
No comment. More points.
Items:
You say start boots and x4 potions. Yet you only talk about 3 in the actual explanation.
You state what you get and why, but you don't state what you don't get and why. I.e,


Playstyles:
Not. blinks.
Skill combinations:
Good.
Early game, mid game, late game:
Fine.
Conclusions:
I'll be watching this guide. It shows potential.
The thing it's desperately missing at the moment to me would be lane-match ups.
When that's done, assuming it's to the same standard as the rest of the guide, will easily result in a +1 from me.
But since it isn't complete at the moment, i'm rating it Ok.
As much as I would love to upvote it, it's a principle of mine to not really vote on incomplete guides.
Want a guide destroyed? reviewed?
albableat wrote:
O_o wat?? +5 AD&AP while ignite is on cooldown
Strictly speaking, ignite itself isnt bring boosted. With or without summoners wrath, target will take same amount of damage from ignite no?
Want a guide destroyed? reviewed?
Thanks for the review! I'm actually kinda tired right now so I'm not going to explain my reasoning for some points you brought out that I disagree with.
Edit'd a lot of the stuff you pointed out already and am working on jungling atm.
Thanks again!
Edit'd a lot of the stuff you pointed out already and am working on jungling atm.
Thanks again!
Totallynotn00b wrote:
Strictly speaking, ignite itself isnt bring boosted. With or without summoners wrath, target will take same amount of damage from ignite no?
Oh, ok then.
I thought you implied that


albableat wrote:
Oh, ok then.
I thought you implied that


nononononono.
God dammit alba is that what you think of me? =(
Want a guide destroyed? reviewed?
Totallynotn00b wrote:
God dammit alba is that what you think of me? =(
That you're the most amazing person on this website? :D
You need to log in before commenting.
<McFly>