Mafia! A game of Heroes and Villains

[quote=mastrer1000][quote=Ekki] Also, revealing your role takes away part of the advantage the role gives (except for Comm Gordon, since you could have Alfred saving you), the prime example being mastrer. If he truly is vengeance seeker, the mafia will know anybody else they kill will be safe.[/quote] I don't think that giving my role away was a disadvantage to me personally at all(I agree that it prohably wasn't really that good for town, although I don't think it was strictly negative). As far as I understand, I pretty much win as long as I don't die and right now, nobody should be trying to kill me because I am the only candidate for vengance seeker.[/quote]

[quote=Ekki]TBH both vengeance seeker and mr freeze are troll roles, so nothing is truly a good/bad idea as long as you enjoy the game. I was just pointing out how revealing your role has clear disadvantages and you were the example at hand :P[/quote]

[quote=Hoppermh]Yeah, I agree not taking action into our own hands has the advantage of possibly lowering the number of mafia we're facing, but lets say TheSilverDust is actually Alfred. We just killed an important townie and left our invest open for death in one round. I was just saying town needs a hint and a nod towards who our healer is and or a hint from Silver what their role might be before we take out 2 towns and possibly end the game here. and for [mention=mastrer1000], I guess revealing that role isn't too bad, but now that just gives mafia a higher chance of knowing who is what role and then making it even harder for town to come back from a game that started 3 mafia : 7 town to now 3? : 4?[/quote]

[quote=Ekki]If TheSilverDust isn't a mafia we already lost unless Alfred actually saves someone the next turn (we can't rely on that anyways). Unfortunately we're with our backs against a corner and our only chance is to kill whoever seems the most suspicious to maximize our chances of not losing on night 3. IMO that person is TheSilverDust, but I could settle with Icecreamy if that's the consensus.[/quote]

[quote=Hoppermh]Orr, we don't kill at random, let Alfred and Gordon take the wheel with the probably 3/4 chance of finding a mafia and going from there. If we have a batman and or the two suicidal bomber roles then there's still achance to keep majority through it all pretty much.[/quote]

[quote=mastrer1000][quote=Hoppermh]Orr, we don't kill at random, let Alfred and Gordon take the wheel with the probably 3/4 chance of finding a mafia and going from there. If we have a batman and or the two suicidal bomber roles then there's still achance to keep majority through it all pretty much.[/quote] the issue with that is that there is no way to confirm that gordon isn't lieing when he claims his role. As far as I'm concerned, the best thing we can do is to jail thesilverdust. I would still suggest this if re4xn hadn't claimed gordon because he was the most obvious in working against town. We don't really have a way to confirm any roles, so I don't see an option other than random killing(and I don't think that it is completly random because icecreamy and silverdust were very obviously trying to distract the town).[/quote]

[quote=Hoppermh]But you saw how we booted Vapora from the game and latest legend died, we possibly helped mafia if we jailed a townie there. I really don't want to jail anyone else until we either get a hint who our doctor may be or if [mention=TheSilverDu...] gives a hint to who they are.[/quote]

[quote=mastrer1000][quote=Hoppermh]But you saw how we booted Vapora from the game and latest legend died, we possibly helped mafia if we jailed a townie there. I really don't want to jail anyone else until we either get a hint who our doctor may be or if [mention=TheSilverDu...] gives a hint to who they are.[/quote] I can agree with everything but the part about getting a hint about the doctor. In my opinion the doctor shouldn't reveal under any cicumstances unless we are about to jail him because there is no way to protect him beyond the one self-heal he has.[/quote]

[quote=Meiyjhe]The day is over. The people at the party overwhelmingly decided to jail TheSilverDust and thus he was to the basement where he was locked up together with Vapora Dark. With the three people dead and two locked up, only five people remain. With that in mind, everyone went back in their rooms. Either to make plans to visit someone that night, or pray that they can live to see another day.[/quote]

[quote=Meiyjhe]Day 3 has started. There was an attempt of murder, but Alfred was able to save the innocent life. It is now up to you to decide who has to be jailed. [url=http://www.pending.me.uk][img]http://www.pending.me.uk/cd/bla_1482016620.png[/img][/url][/quote]