Doran's cloak

[quote=holkos]I thought it would be time for an new doran's item: doran's cloak! [h3]What does it give?[/h3] I was thinking about +100-120 hp, 10 mr and something like 5hp/5 [h3]Why should this be added to lol?[/h3] I think that are not too many defensive options against early-game strong magic users that helps you to survive dmg trades and both block some dmg. I hope you enjoyed my new urge of this item[/quote]

[quote=crossfire]There's a reason no one starts with MR aside from [[galio]], its freaking useless early game unless you mid.[/quote]

[quote=holkos]look, i made this for mid because the current options doesn't suit many champs becuase there are way too offesive options and alomost no defensive options for mid.[/quote]

[quote=Jpikachu1999][[Null-Magic Mantle]] into [[Chalice of Harmony]]. [[Negatron Cloak]] into [[Abyssal Scepter]]. [[Negatron Cloak]] into [[Banshee's Veil]]. [[Chalice of Harmony]] into [[Athene's Unholy Grail]]. [[Lich Bane]], [[Quicksilver Sash]], [[Guardian Angel]]. Plenty of options. I don't see a problem honestly. There is also spellvamp if necessary. Early [[Boots of Speed]] help counteract skill shots, you can even go an early [[Mercury's Treads]] route and get an early [[Void staff]]. It's not a bad idea, but it simply will not be bought over [[Doran's Ring]] or other offensive AP items.[/quote]

[quote=NicknameMy]A more interesting doran's item would be "Doran's Cutter" 80 HP, 8 % Crit Chance, 10 % Attack Speed It could be a nice choice for ad-carries which focus more onto AS and crit than ad and lifesteal. Another option would be to just add 10 mr to [[doran's shield]]. Nobody uses it anyway atm, so this can help.[/quote]

[quote=SkullzX][quote=NicknameMy] A more interesting doran's item would be "Doran's Cutter" 80 HP, 10 % Crit Chance, 10 % Attack Speed It could be a nice choice for ad-carries which focus more onto AS and crit than ad and lifesteal. Another option would be to just add 10 mr to [[doran's shield]]. Nobody uses it anyway atm, so this can help. [/quote] If this was 475 it would be broken as shit because people would just stack 3of them on the first back or so and have a insane 30% crit chance at lv 6 or so 0__0.[/quote]

[quote=PsiGuard][quote=NicknameMy] Another option would be to just add 10 mr to [[doran's shield]]. Nobody uses it anyway atm, so this can help. [/quote] I agree, it probably wouldn't hurt. Right now the only people that run Doran's shield are specific tanks in top lane as far as I know. I think Karthus is the only mid that I would accept a shield on (for some reason it works). Null-magic mantle start is fine if you need early MR (against leblanc or something), but most of the time you'd want boots anyway. And besides what SkullzX said, Riot already removed the old 4% crit chance from masteries. I don't think they're in a hurry to add more crit chance to the laning phase any time soon. And considering [[Brawler's Gloves]] give less CrC than your doran's item, that seems a bit ridiculous. Even without the 10% AS it'd still be ridiculous.[/quote]

[quote=SkullzX]^ yeah what he said. 1650= 45 AD 1425= 30% att speed 30% crit 240 hp! Early crit would just be to broken IMO to give it out because it is such a huge game changer once people get above 25%.[/quote]

[quote=Lugignaf][quote=PsiGuard] Right now the only people that run Doran's shield are specific tanks in top lane as far as I know. I think Karthus is the only mid that I would accept a shield on (for some reason it works). [/quote] HA! Told ya so. Also, giving free MR on an item that builds into nothing is kinda worthless as you're selling already hard to come by stats. Take a look at pre-buff [[chalice of harmony]]. Nobody got it because, it didn't go anywhere and gave minimal stats to the champs that needed it. [quote=NicknameMy] 80 HP, 10 % Crit Chance, 10 % Attack Speed [/quote] Nope. You remember why they took out the crit chance mastery in the offence tree? Lucky crits win lanes and with the mastery, you sacrificed nothing for it. Putting this is is like a [[Tryndamere]]'s wet dream. Sacrifice only a little bit of mobility, which can be made up for with [[spinning slash]], to get some of his best stats in one cheap item. The [[Doran's shield]] buff though is spot-on. I'd like to see it be a really good early tank item. Even more so than it is now.[/quote]

[quote=NicknameMy]Broken doesn't mean it wouldn't be interesting.^^[/quote]