MOBAVERSE Library

[quote=Kazega][quote=tehAsian] I'd like review on my [[diana]] guide :D [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/diana-moonlit-mid-lane-235823]Clicky[/url] I'm also going to stick around and review other guides too :3 [spoiler] Most of the qualms I have with thsi guide come with the build, namely your Jungler build. The issue is that Jungler's shouldn't need GP10 items. I can let kage's lucky pick slide because it builds into Deathfire grasp but otherwise ganks, covering lanes, and the jungle should give you enough money to get by. In my experience: [[Lich bane]] is always first. No excuses. everythign that it does for you is invalueable when both jungling and mid laning. [[Nashor's Tooth]] is a great item, in fact it is my favorite Item in the game. However the fact that it has almost zero applicablityhurts how viable it is in the game. [[Moonsilver blade]] was made for Nashor's tooth, and all the benifits are too great to ignore on Diana. The guide looks great, I jsut disagree with too much right now to give a vote[/spoiler] [/quote][/quote]

[quote=Kazega]I would like to put up my [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/katarina-playing-with-knives-post-rework-239651]Katarina guide[/url] up for Community Review[/quote]

[quote=jhoijhoi][h1]Just a quick reminder to follow the front page format:[/h1] [b]QUOTE[/b] the request (with the working link so other people can check the guide out) [b]SPOILER[/b] your review Please follow this format. It isn't hard. Thanks. Below is a working example. -------------------------- [quote=tehAsian] I'd like review on my [[diana]] guide :D [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/diana-moonlit-mid-lane-235823]Clicky[/url] I'm also going to stick around and review other guides too :3 [/quote] [spoiler]Here is my review, see, this is how it should be set out, please.[/spoiler] Quote my post if you need help with the format.[/quote]

[quote=tehAsian]@Kazega [spoiler=Review Response] [[nashor's tooth]] is terrible. If you build it you're basically saying 'I'm going to ignore all of my other abilities and focus on my PASSIVE. Sure, the CDR is nice. The AP is Okay at best. The mana regen isn't bad. And I'm able to push/out-dps a lot of people with just the passive alone. But [[diana]]'s main focus isn't to DPS people with auto-attacks and her passive (she's too squishy to do that, and does little damage if you decide to build her tanky enough for it), it's to burst down squishies with QRW, then MAYBE her passive if they're still alive and you have the time. Spending time on auto-attacks doesn't contribute to your burst, it lowers it by extending the time you take to deal damage. Additionally, what's the point of auto-attacking, if a full burst combo already kills them? Also, look at its price: it costs 2735. With that much, I can buy a [[deathfire grasp]], which has more AP, more burst, and some of the CDR. Or, I can buy a [[needlessly large rod]] and [[blasting wand]], and obtain twice the amount of AP. Or maybe even a [[void staff]] to do even MORE damage. As for GP5 in the jungle: :l They're necessary. Not all three, but at LEAST one (I swear I said that in my guide). I tend to get all three if I'm ahead enough as it lets you snowball without doing anything, in addition to snowballing regularly since I'm ahead. Also, they can transition into nice tank items as you aren't the AP Mid in your team, so you can allow your damage to be secondary. [[lich bane]] first implies, again, you're focusing on your passive, and if you get it that early the bonus damage probably won't do you any good. Oh yeah, I saw a [[lich bane]] rush on jungle [[diana]]. Not that great, I should say. [/spoiler] [quote=Kazega] I would like to put up my [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/katarina-playing-with-knives-post-rework-239651]Katarina guide[/url] up for Community Review [/quote] [spoiler=Review] IMO [[kage's lucky pick]] should come earlier. Everything else is pretty much how I build Kat :P 3/3 [[brute force]] and 3/4 [[mental force]] is better for pretty much everything :P In abilities section: [[sinister steel]] - The wording is kind of confusing. [quote] It should be maxed second because the AoE is not needed as much in the laning phase.[/quote] It sounds kind of like "if you don't need it, max it second." I think you should note you can [[shunpo]] to wards or similar things. Summoner Spells: I don't think you should list every (or almost every :P) single summoner spell, but just the viable ones or the ones that aren't obvious. Items: I think [[guardian angel]] is a good situational item :P Also, Summoner's Rift: [b]Early[/b] [quote] at 1:55, throw Bouncing blade through the wall towards the Blue Golem and make your way to the lane.[/quote] "If you have a jungler." or "To leash the Golem" Because guides are mostly meant to help low elo/unranked players, and sometimes there won't be a jungler :P The people you're ganking don't necessarily need to be low for it to be successful. Also, you spelled 'favorable' wrong, and excellent damage output isn't always there. I suggest you rethink these four points. Also, y u no take your own wraiths, and only enemy wraiths? :O [b]Mid Game[/b] Sight Wards are incorrectly coded. I don't play Dominion, so I'm not going to comment. Everything here is fantastic actually, one of the better guides on the site. Keep up the good work~![/spoiler][/quote]

[quote=Xeronn]Also try to not fill this thread with unnecessary comments, otherwise it'll be a lot harder to find guides.[/quote]

[quote=Roronoa EvrIs]Hello everyone! I'd like to put up my currently [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/ap-tank-shen-ninja-gaiden-in-lol-196144#chapter20]#1 guide on Shen[/url] for some reviews. And i'll be here to return the favor for the next 2 weeks![/quote]

[quote=KSS Awake]I will put [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/skarner-the-trinity-tank-beast-235676]my Skarner guide[/url] here and I will be reviewing guides as soon as possible.[/quote]

[quote=KSS Awake][quote=Slaydis] Hi! Here is [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/fiddlesticks-the-master-of-crows-a-mean-in-depth-guide-234139]my[/url] guide. Plz check out the "Discussion" as i responded to some questions there. Thank you in advance, Slaydis- [/quote] [spoiler] Was going not to vote at all but then I saw that you explained why to max E first. Very well formatted and in depth. Altough I can't understand why is not [[talon]] on the hard mid laners list? +1 definitely deserved [/spoiler] [quote=Roronoa EvrIs] Hello everyone! I'd like to put up my currently [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/ap-tank-shen-ninja-gaiden-in-lol-196144#chapter20]#1 guide on Shen[/url] for some reviews. And i'll be here to return the favor for the next 2 weeks! [/quote] [spoiler] Go ap shen for 150 AP thus meaning your W will absorb extra 90 damage compared to pure tank and that your huge cooldown ultimate will absorb 255 more damage. Is it really worth it? I am not even going to consider the extra damage as it is very low to actually make a difference. I am thinking that pure tank shen is more viable and a better choice but you put hard work into proving a new concept so you have my upvote. [/spoiler][/quote]

[quote=Roronoa EvrIs][quote=KSS Awake] I will put [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/skarner-the-trinity-tank-beast-235676]my Skarner guide[/url] here and I will be reviewing guides as soon as possible. [/quote] [Spoiler]You sir have one of the best guides in Mobafire. Great coding and a lot of information. I can't really find anything to criticize except that you should mention that your ulti can be used to break channeling ulties like Nunu's. +1 from me and +rep![/Spoiler][/quote]

[quote=Roronoa EvrIs][quote=KSS Awake] [quote=Roronoa EvrIs] Hello everyone! I'd like to put up my currently [url=http://www.mobafire.com/league-of-legends/build/ap-tank-shen-ninja-gaiden-in-lol-196144#chapter20]#1 guide on Shen[/url] for some reviews. And i'll be here to return the favor for the next 2 weeks! [/quote] [spoiler] Go ap shen for 150 AP thus meaning your W will absorb extra 90 damage compared to pure tank and that your huge cooldown ultimate will absorb 255 more damage. Is it really worth it? I am not even going to consider the extra damage as it is very low to actually make a difference. I am thinking that pure tank shen is more viable and a better choice but you put hard work into proving a new concept so you have my upvote. [/spoiler] [/quote] From my games as Shen i find that this 255 extra shield make a big fidderence as its almost like giving your carry a second life. Also with your armor stats this 90 extra shield will let you tank a lot more as it won't fade away even by 3 or towerhits.[/quote]